Ranking assumes full PPR, one QB, no IDP. Set your league
See only your players' newsConnect
Signal 29 most important first
-
Giants-Texans pregame thoughts:
• There are different games during the season when you feel like you can learn a lot about a team. This feels like one of those games after the coaches turned up the heat this week. Had Harbaugh calling out a running back — any running back — to step up and Dennard Wilson putting the defense's effort on blast. This team has proven to be mentally tough this season, so we'll see how they respond today.
• JJ McCarthy is a total wild card. Really impossible to predict what we'll see him from today. But I do expect the offense to shift back to what we saw in the opener. McCarthy's legs should help open up some lanes on zone read. But the Texans have a stout run defense. Won't be easy to just ground-and-pound their way through this one.
• Cam Skattebo is out of the doghouse. Expecting a time share with Tyrone Tracy, with Devin Singletary mixed in. Harbaugh hoping someone emerges and they can ride that back.
• Malik Nabers has been on a tear: 6-112-1,…
Why it's #1 Cam Skattebo (top-50) · 6 reports
59 more updatesfrom 23 sources
- Oct 26 Pat Leonard (X) JACK MAC DEBRIEF NFL WEEK 7 🏈JJ McCarthy ditched the eyeblack to beat CJ Stroud once again 🏈Skattebo calls out the NFL 🏈Joe Burrow…a tale of 2 halves 🏈The Jets return to factory settings 🏈Butker has a STINKER…K9 runs off 🏈Legendary ref 🏈By the order of the French Peaky Bliders MUCH MORE
- Oct 25 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy Delivers a Winning Debut as Giants Starter, Beating Texans in Overtime
- Oct 25 Yahoo Fantasy Football Fantasy Football: J.J. McCarthy's first start as a Giant proves victorious — but did he truly move the needle?
- Oct 25 Dan Duggan (X) JJ McCarthy had hit a dead end in his career, stuck as the third-string QB for a team that was done with him. Then came the trade to the Giants. Now, suddenly the future looks much brighter for McCarthy and the Giants
- Oct 25 Albert Breer (X) JJ McCarthy showed a little something today. · Quoting Mina Kimes: ….man what
- Oct 25 Mina Kimes (Bluesky) *lowers voice to a barely audible whisper* JJ McCarthy made some legit impressive throws today guys
- Oct 25 CBS Sports NFL Headlines J.J. McCarthy, Cam Skattebo seize second chances as John Harbaugh's surprising Giants keep rolling
- Oct 25 CBS Sports NFL Headlines NFL Week 7 winners and losers: Cam Skattebo, J.J. McCarthy lift Giants; Aaron Glenn's seat heats up
- Oct 25 Giants Team Site Inside the Numbers: J.J. McCarthy's winning start with the Giants
- Oct 25 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) JJ McCarthy gets a win in his first start as the Giants QB. Repost of @NFL+1
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) Giants are the clear favorites in the NFC East. They are 4-2-1 heading into the bye week. And J.J. McCarthy was impressive while playing clean football. · Quoting Jordan Raanan: J.J. McCarthy's arm put them in position to win. The running game won it for the Giants. Big win as 10-point road dogs. Giants 27, Texans 21
- Oct 25 Pat Leonard (X) Every JJ McCarthy throw and run vs the Texans 🔥 – 20/28 – 252 yards – Sacked 3x – 99.1 Rating #NYGIANTS
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy's arm put them in position to win. The running game won it for the Giants. Big win as 10-point road dogs. Giants 27, Texans 21
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy has a chance right now to be a hero. Giants get the ball, tie game, 52 seconds remaining. He's been great so far today.
- Oct 25 Aaron Wilson (X) #Giants lead #Texans 21-14 in fourth quarter, and offense has to answer. Defense has been substandard again for Texans. They've allowed 337 yards of total offense. J.J. McCarthy 16 of 23 for 231 yards. Cam Skattebo 15 runs for 81 yards. Malik Nabers four catches, 94 yards
- Oct 25 Pat Leonard (X) Another really good throw by J.J. McCarthy to rookie receiver Malachi Fields for the first down conversion Fields is having by far his best game of his first NFL season to date Cam Skattebo then breaks multiple tackles on an impressive touchdown run 21-14 Giants with 855 to play after that 14 play, 80-yard drive
- Oct 25 Dan Duggan (X) Big-time throw by JJ McCarthy because it was an awesome throw. And also because no one wanted to see a 48-yard FG attempt there.
- Oct 25 Aaron Wilson (X) A sack for #Texan corner Kamari Lassiter, delivering a big play on third down as Jadeveon Clowney flushed out J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) Great throw and catch on third down by J.J. McCarthy and Malachi Fields. Super tight window.
- Oct 25 Aaron Wilson (X) #Texans halftime thoughts and key numbers: Tied ballgame at 14-14 after C.J. Stroud touchdown pass to Marvin Harrison Jr., and two-point pass to Cade Stover. All @OhioStateFB scoring there. Sparked by huge 43-yard catch and runs over middle by Tank Dell in first catch, game since 2024 touchdown and major knee injury vs. #Chiefs Giants had chance for halftime lead but miss the field goal wide right. Texans penalties, including special-teams one on Ja'Marcus Ingram, have been costly and plentiful: Nine for 70 yards in first half. Texans defense vulnerable to big plays, allowing passes of 42, 47 and 29 yards. Malik Nabers doing damage to secondary with four catches for 94 yards on five targets. J.J. McCarthy taking advantage of opportunity with 9 of 12 passing for 178 yards. C.J. Stroud heating up toward end of half, 10 of 15 for 108 yards. Dalton Schultz most consistent target: four catches for 38 yards on four targets.
- Oct 25 rivers mccown (Bluesky) Justin Jefferson was holding J.J. McCarthy back, my column
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) The word to describe J.J. McCarthy in the first half -- composed. Has been in control, no panic. McCarthy: 9 of 12 for 178 yards, led 2 TD drives. Two other potential scoring drives too with the missed FGs.
- Oct 25 Aaron Wilson (X) #Giants Malik Nabers up to four catches for 94 yards on five targets. And J.J. McCarthy 9 for 11, 178 yards
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy dealing. Great throw to Malik Nabers. Right on the mark.
- Oct 25 Josina Anderson (X) A NEW GURU: Take a look at your newly-minted TUSH PUSH connoisseur #Giants QB2 Jameis Winston. Have to admit, I do like the way Matt Nagy is keeping Winston involved after losing the starting nod to J.J McCarthy. The QB switch was the right call, but this is also just a really intelligent way to keep your backup engaged, involved & rewarded for being a great teammate. · Quoting JosinaAnderson: HARBAUGH FIRED UP ON THIS SKATTEBO FLAG: Do you think unnecessary toughness should’ve been called on #Giants RB Cam Skattebo on this play? Should this be impermissible use of a helmet for running back trying to gain yards in the hole?
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) Great throwback pass from J.J. McCarthy to Thomas Fidone sets up another Giants TD. Jameis Winston with the tush-push 1-yard TD. Giants 14, Texans 6
- Oct 25 Dan Duggan (X) Such an impressive first half from the Giants so far. JJ McCarthy has been excellent: 8-9 for 151 yards. Key will be closing this out and keeping the momentum going into halftime. They get the ball to start the second half.
- Oct 25 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) JJ McCarthy uses his mobility to avoid the rush and hits Malik for a first down in Houston territory.
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) The Giants had Jalin Hyatt open deep but pressure on J.J. McCarthy forced a slightly off-target throw. Penalty on the play anyway so Giants first down.
- Oct 25 Aaron Wilson (X) #Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy 6 for 7 for 105 yards, 118.8 passer rating, sacked once
- Oct 25 Pat Leonard (X) Big-time 47-yard catch and run from Malachi Fields on 3rd and 17 for the Giants on that sideline throw by J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 25 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy just cuts out all the bullshit. No completions shorter than 22 yards
- Oct 25 rivers mccown (Bluesky) Watching the Texans defense get destroyed by J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 25 Pro Football Talk J.J. McCarthy, Giants take 7-3 lead on Texans+1
- Oct 25 Pat Leonard (X) Texans had no safety help over Nabers out of the slot in 1-on-1 coverage. Good luck with that · Quoting Pat Leonard: J.J. McCarthy delivers a 42-yard deep shot to Malik Nabers in 1-on-1 coverage vs. Kamari Lassiter out of the slot. That's Nabers' bread and butter right there McCarthy runs the Giants' offense up to the 2-yard line and read options a handoff to Tyrone Tracy Jr. for the 2-yard TD run 7-3 Giants 626 left in the 1st Q
- Oct 25 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) Kevin O'Connell is about to become The Music Man if he made the wrong call on both Sam Darnold and J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 25 NFL Daily News (Bluesky) JJ MCCARTHY GOES DEEP TO MALIK NABERS+1
- Oct 25 Aaron Wilson (X) Here's #Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy 42-yard pass to Malik Nabers vs. #Texans
- Oct 25 Dan Duggan (X) Matt Nagy has done such a good job of getting Malik Nabers favorable matchusp out of the slot. He torched Kamari Lassiter on a slot fade for that 42-yard gain. Great first drive for JJ McCarthy and the offense.
- Oct 25 Denny Carter (Bluesky) JJ McCarthy is so so much better than Kyler lmao
- Oct 25 Andrew Krammer (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy's New York Giants are up 7-3...
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) John Harbaugh goes for a fourth-and-2 early in game near midfield. Jet sweep to Darnell Mooney for first down. Next play ... J.J. McCarthy hits deep ball to Malik Nabers for 42 yards.
- Oct 25 Pat Leonard (X) Jameis Winston enters on 3rd and short to run the tush push on the 3rd offensive play. Winston gets it, and J.J. McCarthy come back in
- Oct 25 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) Not sure I've ever had a more "get that paper" Sunday setup than suddenly being all in on J.J. McCarthy in a pair of two-QB leagues
- Oct 25 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Rapoport] Giants RB Cam Skattebo is expected to resume his role as the team’s lead back vs. the Texans. Plus, JJ McCarthy has a long leash.
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) Kind of think it's a no-lose situation for J.J. McCarthy. If it goes poorly, can easily be excused off as they were 10-point underdogs. If he plays well and they keep it close or win, it's hey maybe the Giants have something here. #Giants #Texans
- Oct 25 Pro Football Talk J.J. McCarthy carries four-game winning streak into first start for Giants
- Oct 25 Yahoo Fantasy Football Giants stun Texans in J.J. McCarthy's first start, Cam Skattebo's return to seize control of NFC East
- Oct 25 Yahoo Fantasy Football Giants vs. Texans live updates, inactives, where to watch: J.J. McCarthy named starter over Jameis Winston; Tank Dell makes return from knee injury in Week 7
- Oct 25 Dan Duggan (X) Giants-Texans pregame thoughts: • There are different games during the season when you feel like you can learn a lot about a team. This feels like one of those games after the coaches turned up the heat this week. Had Harbaugh calling out a running back — any running back — to step up and Dennard Wilson putting the defense's effort on blast. This team has proven to be mentally tough this season, so we'll see how they respond today. • JJ McCarthy is a total wild card. Really impossible to predict what we'll see him from today. But I do expect the offense to shift back to what we saw in the opener. McCarthy's legs should help open up some lanes on zone read. But the Texans have a stout run defense. Won't be easy to just ground-and-pound their way through this one. • Cam Skattebo is out of the doghouse. Expecting a time share with Tyrone Tracy, with Devin Singletary mixed in. Harbaugh hoping someone emerges and they can ride that back. • Malik Nabers has been on a tear: 6-112-1,…
- Oct 25 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy arrives for his first Giants start in Houston with fullback Pat Ricard lead blocking #talkinball @NYDNSports
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy here to make his first start with the Giants. No soft landing against a tough Texans defense on the road. The Giants are hoping that McCarthy can jumpstart their running game.
- Oct 25 PFF News NFL Week 7: Same-game parlays
- Oct 25 Jordan Raanan (X) Cam Skattebo back as the lead back. I'm expecting Tyrone Tracy Jr. also heavily in the mix, probably close to a 50/50 split. · Quoting Ian Rapoport: #Giants RB Cam Skattebo is expected to resume his role as the team’s lead back vs. the #Texans. Plus, JJ McCarthy has a long leash. My story
- Oct 25 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) The Giants once had Eli Manning start 210 straight regular-season games. On Sunday, J.J. McCarthy will become the Giants’ 12th different starting QB since Manning retired after the 2019 season.+1
- Oct 25 Mike Garafolo (X) A one-week stay in the doghouse for Skattebo, who will have ball security on his mind as he leads the way for the #Giants’ backfield against the #Texans. · Quoting Ian Rapoport: #Giants RB Cam Skattebo is expected to resume his role as the team’s lead back vs. the #Texans. Plus, JJ McCarthy has a long leash. My story
-
Every time I hear Warner’s analysis I wonder why he doesn’t have an even bigger platform. He provides insight like a QB expert and not someone just hyping everyone.
To his points on McCarthy, I think Nagy deserves a ton of credit for scheming up so many plays where the first read was open, and then McCarthy’s arm talent took over. Will be interesting to see the progress as they face more complicated defenses scheming to take away what they’ve put on film · Quoting Rich Eisen Show: 💻 @kurt13warner
Has #BigBlue found their QB in JJ McCarthy? What's the film study show after the Week 7 win in Houston?
#NFL
Why it's #2 a starter
5 more updatesfrom 3 sources
- 5d Jordan Raanan (X) Interesting stuff on J.J. McCarthy move and more ... · Quoting Move The Sticks Podcast: Today on Move the Sticks: 🔵 @Giants GM Joe Schoen joins! 🏈 Working with John Harbaugh 🤔 Why JJ McCarthy was brought in & his impact 📈 Malik Nabers-Isaiah Likely potential 👀 Plus previewing Week 8 & three FUN trade ideas WATCH ⬇️ 🔗: #Giants
- 5d Adam Schefter (X) There now have been seven in-season trades. Since 2022, there have been an average of 17 trades per year from Oct. 1 up until the trade deadline. In each of the past two seasons, as it has become trendier to make blockbuster deals, there have been 18 trades from Oct. 1 up until the deadline. This year’s deadline is Tuesday Nov. 10. · Quoting Adam Schefter: NFL trades since Sept 28: 🏈DT Jeffery Simmons to the Bears 🏈DT DeForest Buckner to the 49ers 🏈G Quenton Nelson to the Seahawks 🏈WR Marvin Harrison Jr. to the Texans 🏈C Cam Jurgens to the Ravens 🏈CB Joey Porter Jr. to the Cowboys 🏈QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants.
- 5d Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) NFL trades since Sept 28: 🏈DT Jeffery Simmons to the Bears 🏈DT DeForest Buckner to the 49ers 🏈G Quenton Nelson to the Seahawks 🏈WR Marvin Harrison Jr. to the Texans 🏈C Cam Jurgens to the Ravens 🏈CB Joey Porter Jr. to the Cowboys 🏈QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants.+1
- 5d Jordan Raanan (X) Today on Move the Sticks: 🔵 @Giants GM Joe Schoen joins! 🏈 Working with John Harbaugh 🤔 Why JJ McCarthy was brought in & his impact 📈 Malik Nabers-Isaiah Likely potential 👀 Plus previewing Week 8 & three FUN trade ideas WATCH ⬇️ 🔗: #Giants
- 5d Dan Duggan (X) Every time I hear Warner’s analysis I wonder why he doesn’t have an even bigger platform. He provides insight like a QB expert and not someone just hyping everyone. To his points on McCarthy, I think Nagy deserves a ton of credit for scheming up so many plays where the first read was open, and then McCarthy’s arm talent took over. Will be interesting to see the progress as they face more complicated defenses scheming to take away what they’ve put on film · Quoting Rich Eisen Show: 💻 @kurt13warner Has #BigBlue found their QB in JJ McCarthy? What's the film study show after the Week 7 win in Houston? #NFL
-
"I was pretty harsh on the trade, harsh on J.J. He's made me look pretty dumb these five quarters he's played. I still think my skepticism was warranted - I think a lot of people just wanted to believe that he was good because the Giants traded for him.
If you go back to the end of his time in Minnesota, I probably didn't weigh that enough that he was starting to play better those last couple of games. We'll see, this is a long way to go, but man, it would be impossible for him to have looked better in his first quarters here." - @DDuggan21
Dan and @Connor_J_Hughes talk J.J. McCarthy on NYG411
Why it's #3 a starter
5 more updatesfrom 5 sources
- Oct 27 Jordan Raanan (X) What's the future of the Giants QB room with Jaxson Dart, J.J. McCarthy and Jameis Winston? Joe Schoen: "Good position to be in." Dart and McCarthy are viewed as good young quarterbacks. Winston a backup you can win games with. Giants went 2-1-1 with him as starter.
- Oct 27 Dan Duggan (X) I was skeptical of the JJ McCarthy trade, but his first five quarters have certainly made me start to believe… · Quoting SNY Giants: "I was pretty harsh on the trade, harsh on J.J. He's made me look pretty dumb these five quarters he's played. I still think my skepticism was warranted - I think a lot of people just wanted to believe that he was good because the Giants traded for him. If you go back to the end of his time in Minnesota, I probably didn't weigh that enough that he was starting to play better those last couple of games. We'll see, this is a long way to go, but man, it would be impossible for him to have looked better in his first quarters here." - @DDuggan21 Dan and @Connor_J_Hughes talk J.J. McCarthy on NYG411
- Oct 27 Dan Duggan (X) "I was pretty harsh on the trade, harsh on J.J. He's made me look pretty dumb these five quarters he's played. I still think my skepticism was warranted - I think a lot of people just wanted to believe that he was good because the Giants traded for him. If you go back to the end of his time in Minnesota, I probably didn't weigh that enough that he was starting to play better those last couple of games. We'll see, this is a long way to go, but man, it would be impossible for him to have looked better in his first quarters here." - @DDuggan21 Dan and @Connor_J_Hughes talk J.J. McCarthy on NYG411
- Oct 27 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) The NFL heading into Week 8: 🏈Chargers are last winless team. 🏈Vikings are last unbeaten team. 🏈Browns, led by Deshaun Watson, are in first place. 🏈Giants, led by JJ McCarthy, are in first place. Cc: @tyschmit 🎧+1
- Oct 27 Daily Norseman (MIN) The McCarthy/Murray Discourse Isn’t Going Away
-
I'll get to the defense shortly, but wanted to post this before anyone else gets cut! · Quoting Dan Duggan: Not enough hours in Mondays lately! Better late than never, here's the Giants' offensive snap counts vs. the Saints:
• Nobody, including Harbaugh, likes a four-man RB rotation. That needs to end. Eliminating Najee Harris from the equation is the obvious call. I note every week here how he has no juice. If he does fall out of the rotation, I wouldn't be surprised if he becomes the next vet sent packing.
Devin Singletary has done a nice job in limited reps, so if they want to keep him in the mix, maybe as the third-down back, that's fine. But it's time to go back to featuring Cam Skattebo and Tyrone Tracy. They're the best RBs on the roster. And both should benefit whenever the change to JJ McCarthy comes, as that will open up some lanes on zone reads.
Tracy played well Sunday considering no RB got anything going on the ground. Impressive YAC on the TD and multiple strong…
7 more updatesfrom 6 sources
- Oct 20 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants at a Crossroads: Is It Time to Turn the Offense Over to J.J. McCarthy?
- Oct 20 RotoBaller NFL Wide Receiver (WR) Fantasy Football Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Picks for Week 7 (2026)
- Oct 20 Pat Leonard (X) I think the Giants should stick with Jameis Winston this week. I also think they’re going to start J.J. McCarthy anyway in Houston @NYDNSports
- Oct 20 Dan Duggan (X) I'll get to the defense shortly, but wanted to post this before anyone else gets cut! · Quoting Dan Duggan: Not enough hours in Mondays lately! Better late than never, here's the Giants' offensive snap counts vs. the Saints: • Nobody, including Harbaugh, likes a four-man RB rotation. That needs to end. Eliminating Najee Harris from the equation is the obvious call. I note every week here how he has no juice. If he does fall out of the rotation, I wouldn't be surprised if he becomes the next vet sent packing. Devin Singletary has done a nice job in limited reps, so if they want to keep him in the mix, maybe as the third-down back, that's fine. But it's time to go back to featuring Cam Skattebo and Tyrone Tracy. They're the best RBs on the roster. And both should benefit whenever the change to JJ McCarthy comes, as that will open up some lanes on zone reads. Tracy played well Sunday considering no RB got anything going on the ground. Impressive YAC on the TD and multiple strong…
- Oct 20 Dan Duggan (X) Not enough hours in Mondays lately! Better late than never, here's the Giants' offensive snap counts vs. the Saints: • Nobody, including Harbaugh, likes a four-man RB rotation. That needs to end. Eliminating Najee Harris from the equation is the obvious call. I note every week here how he has no juice. If he does fall out of the rotation, I wouldn't be surprised if he becomes the next vet sent packing. Devin Singletary has done a nice job in limited reps, so if they want to keep him in the mix, maybe as the third-down back, that's fine. But it's time to go back to featuring Cam Skattebo and Tyrone Tracy. They're the best RBs on the roster. And both should benefit whenever the change to JJ McCarthy comes, as that will open up some lanes on zone reads. Tracy played well Sunday considering no RB got anything going on the ground. Impressive YAC on the TD and multiple strong blitz pick-ups. By far Pat Ricard's smallest workload. Part of that is obviously that they were in throw-only…
- Oct 20 Dan Duggan (X) As we wait to find out if JJ McCarthy will start this week, the big question is if his fourth quarter performance was real or the product of "desperation time?"
- Oct 20 Jordan Raanan (X) Jameis Winston vs. J.J. McCarthy pros and cons.
- Oct 20 ESPN NFL News Jameis Winston vs. J.J. McCarthy: Pros and cons of Giants QBs
-
This was only a matter of time, especially after the way he played on Sunday vs. Saints. The Giants traded a draft pick for J.J. McCarthy.
He's now is in line to make his first start against the Texans. · Quoting Jeremy Fowler: Source: The Giants plan to start J.J. McCarthy on Sunday vs. Houston.
58 more updatesfrom 26 sources
- Oct 21 Jeremy Fowler (X) J.J. McCarthy provided a spark with his arm and his legs last week vs. New Orleans. In his first start as a Giant, New York is counting on his mobility to help the offense. More via @JordanRaanan+1
- Oct 21 Jordan Raanan (X) The way it turned out: John Harbaugh spoke to Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy 1-on-1 on Tuesday. Told them the QB plan. He didn't think it was necessary to make a big announcement to the team. Most players learned the news once they started to get into game plan on Wednesday. · Quoting Jordan Raanan: The #Giants didn't tell the players about a quarterback decision yesterday between Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy. They went over film from this past week's game. Would expect it to be addressed this morning at meetings. Practice at 1 pm.
- Oct 21 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) More about the New York Giants turning to J.J. McCarthy as their starting quarterback for Sunday’s game against the Houston Texans, via @JordanRaanan+2
- Oct 21 Dan Duggan (X) I think the focus on JJ McCarthy's ability to scramble is missing the mark. Sure, it's great to have a QB who can get out of trouble in the pocket. But his much bigger impact will be on the run game because now the zone-read (and everything Greg Roman will devise off of that) is now a viable part of the playbook again. They have clearly missed post-Dart · Quoting SNY Giants: 🚨 Emergency episode! 🚨 On NYG411, @Connor_J_Hughes and @DDuggan21 react to J.J. McCarthy being named the Giants' starting QB and how his mobility could become an advantage
- Oct 21 Dan Duggan (X) 🚨 Emergency episode! 🚨 On NYG411, @Connor_J_Hughes and @DDuggan21 react to J.J. McCarthy being named the Giants' starting QB and how his mobility could become an advantage
- Oct 21 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy is in. Was it the right call? We break down every angle including for the future. on the new Locked On Giants podcast episode. Photo: John Jones - IMAGN Images
- Oct 21 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) I traded Jameson Williams for J.J. McCarthy in a two-QB league where I drafted Jalen Hurts and Justin Herbert
- Oct 21 Dan Duggan (X) Quick pod on the QB change · Quoting Connor Hughes: The #Giants have a new QB … it’s JJ McCarthy. What’s it mean? How will this unlock the offense? Can he get them to the playoffs? A special edition episode of #NYG411 with @DDuggan21
- Oct 21 Pat Leonard (X) John Harbaugh benched Jameis Winston and named J.J. McCarthy his starting quarterback on Wednesday for the Giants’ Week 7 road game against the Houston Texans. And the Giants’ players accepted it, starting with Winston, because they understood and respected why Harbaugh was doing it: The Giants‘ head coach is determined to win the NFC East, and he is not accepting anything that he believes is getting in the way of that goal
- Oct 21 Pro Football Talk J.J. McCarthy on feeling more ready to start: Experience does wonders
- Oct 21 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Harbaugh Explains Switch to J.J. McCarthy at QB: “This Is Going to Be Our Direction”
- Oct 21 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy is the Giants starting quarterback for the foreseeable future. As a matter of fact, Harbaugh thought it was a pretty obvious move because it was the "right time." Harbaugh met with the QBs 1-on-1 Tuesday. Made no grand announcement Wednesday. Most of the players found out as they went over the game plan.
- Oct 21 Dan Duggan (X) The #Giants have a new QB … it’s JJ McCarthy. What’s it mean? How will this unlock the offense? Can he get them to the playoffs? A special edition episode of #NYG411 with @DDuggan21
- Oct 21 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) Nailed this, from the moment the Giants traded an asset for him. This was the inevitable outcome. · Quoting Rotoworld Football: Fowler: J.J. McCarthy will start Week 7 vs. Texans
- Oct 21 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy stayed after practice on Wednesday to get in extra work with his starting receivers, including Malik Nabers. Necessary because, as McCarthy said the other day, he had barely even thrown to Nabers prior to the Saints game.
- Oct 21 Pat Leonard (X) WATCH: J.J. McCarthy grateful to be Giants starting quarterback in Week 7 at Houston Texans @YouTube+2
- Oct 21 Pat Leonard (X) 🎥John Harbaugh’s full press conference announcing J.J. McCarthy as Giants starting QB @YouTube
- Oct 21 FTN (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy is taking over as the Giants starting QB 🗽 @jeffratcliffe.bsky.social details the fantasy breakdown for McCarthy, Malik Nabers, Isaiah Likely & what’s next for the New York backfield 🧐
- Oct 21 Yahoo Fantasy Football J.J. McCarthy named starter for Giants: What could it mean for the fantasy outlooks of Malik Nabers, Isaiah Likely?
- Oct 21 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) John Harbaugh says J.J. McCarthy gives #NYGiants "best chance" to be the offense they want to be.
- Oct 21 Aaron Wilson (X) 'J.J. opens up zone read, escape the pocket, young quarterback, we have to rush together' #Texans Will Anderson Jr. on J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 21 Pro Football Talk John Harbaugh: Starting J.J. McCarthy is the plan going forward
- Oct 21 Aaron Wilson (X) 'You see the athleticism with J.J. some designed reads, gave offense and team a spark, they saw some belief from their entire team, I see why they named him the starting quarterback,' #Texans coach DeMeco Ryans on J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 21 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy says he's honored but "not surprised" to be the starting quarterback of the Giants. Feels he's more ready to be a starter than his time in Minnesota. "Experience does wonders," he said.
- Oct 21 Albert Breer (X) JJ McCarthy officially now the Giants starter. · Quoting SNY Giants: John Harbaugh confirms that J.J. McCarthy will start on Sunday for the Giants
- Oct 21 Aaron Wilson (X) 'It doesn't really matter who plays quarterback, it's been about our process whoever's in at quarterback doesn't dictate for us. We have to play better defensively. We have to tackle better' #Texans DeMeco Ryans on #Giants shift to J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 21 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) John Harbaugh confirmed Giants QB J.J. McCarthy will replace Jameis Winston and start Sunday’s game at Houston, as @jeremeyfowler reported.+2
- Oct 21 Albert Breer (X) John Harbaugh confirms that J.J. McCarthy will start on Sunday for the Giants
- Oct 21 Mike Garafolo (X) John Harbaugh confirms J.J. McCarthy is the new #Giants starting QB. · Quoting Jeremy Fowler: Source: The Giants plan to start J.J. McCarthy on Sunday vs. Houston.
- Oct 21 Dan Duggan (X) JJ McCarthy throwing after practice with Malik Nabers, Darnell Mooney and Malachi Fields.
- Oct 21 Jordan Raanan (X) I asked QB coach Brian Callahan on Friday if J.J. McCarthy was ready to handle a full workload, if necessary: “To be fair to him, you definitely would make sure he's got a good solid amount of plays that he feels great about. And there may be some things that he's a little bit newer, too, that you stay away from. But I would say, for the most part, I feel pretty good about him being able to operate a game plan at this point.
- Oct 21 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy is going to become an issue in the Minnesota senate race
- Oct 21 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Big move for the Giants. J.J. McCarthy gets the start to unlock the offense. RPOs and designed runs are back to stretch the defense. Time to pivot. #NYGiants #NFLUpdates #JJMcCarthy #NFLNews #GiantsFootball #NFLSeason #FootballAnalysis
- Oct 21 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy is 1st Giants QB up to start Wednesday’s practice, handing the ball to … Cam Skattebo. Players not practicing includes: OTs Andrew Thomas, Jermaine Eluemunor & Marcus Mbow; middle LB Tremaine Edmunds, safety Jevón Holland (running on back field with trainer) & corner Greg Newsome
- Oct 21 Dan Duggan (X) Arguments could be made for either decision. This is definitely the more exciting one · Quoting Jeremy Fowler: Source: The Giants plan to start J.J. McCarthy on Sunday vs. Houston.
- Oct 21 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) Nine is back — And this time he's sparing nobody. Catch J.J. McCarthy in Blumhouse Films' "Nine Returns"
- Oct 21 rivers mccown (Bluesky) the wise man bowed his head solemnly after the texans d/st scored three points this week and spoke: "theres actually zero difference between good & bad things. you imbecile. you fucking moron" · Quoting Rotoworld Football: Fowler: J.J. McCarthy will start Week 7 vs. Texans
- Oct 21 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Fowler] The Giants plan to start J.J. McCarthy on Sunday vs. Houston.+2
- Oct 21 Pat Leonard (X) One interesting part of John Harbaugh switching QBs is that the Giants' offense was not involved at all in the biggest swing of Sunday's loss to the Saints. The Giants led 10-0 with 2:27 left in the 2nd Q: ⚫️ Special teams: Allowed 41-yard kick return to NO 44 yard-line. Saints kick a 58-yard FG SCORE: 10-3 ⚫️ Special teams: Charlie Jones fumble gives Saints 1st and 10 at Giants 28-yard line with 1:11 left in 2nd Q ⚫️ Defense: Allows 25-yard Tyler Shough scramble. Saints score a TD on 4th and goal HALFTIME SCORE: 10-10 ⚫️ Defense: Allows 5-play, 79-yard Saints TD drive. SCORE: 17-10 Saints Only then did the Giants' offense get the ball back in its hands. And yes, Winston's offense was a mess after that before the QB switch: ⚫️ Three straight penalties and Punt ⚫️ Interception ⚫️ 3rd down sack and Punt ⚫️ Interception I just don't think the quarterback is the reason the Giants are playing too much losing football in stretches lately. Maybe J.J. McCarthy can rescue the rest…
- Oct 21 Rotoworld Football (Bluesky) Fowler: J.J. McCarthy will start Week 7 vs. Texans+2
- Oct 21 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Breaking: J.J. McCarthy has been named the Giants' starting quarterback for the coming week per a report from ESPN. I'll have a breakdown of the decision and more in a special episode of the Locked On Giants podcast. (Photo: John Jones-Imagn Images)
- Oct 21 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Report: Giants Will Start J.J. McCarthy Over Jameis Winston Against Texans
- Oct 21 Jordan Raanan (X) This was only a matter of time, especially after the way he played on Sunday vs. Saints. The Giants traded a draft pick for J.J. McCarthy. He's now is in line to make his first start against the Texans. · Quoting Jeremy Fowler: Source: The Giants plan to start J.J. McCarthy on Sunday vs. Houston.
- Oct 21 Pat Leonard (X) As expected, Harbaugh breaks the glass and goes to J.J. · Quoting Jeremy Fowler: Source: The Giants plan to start J.J. McCarthy on Sunday vs. Houston.
- Oct 21 RotoBaller NFL Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 7? Matthew Stafford, Geno Smith, Patrick Mahomes, Baker Mayfield, JJ Mccarthy, Michael Penix, Brock Purdy, Deshaun Watson, Tanner Mckee
- Oct 21 FantasyPros (YouTube) Fantasy Football NYG FALLOUT: Cam Skattebo, JJ McCarthy & More! #shorts
- Oct 21 Pat Leonard (X) Jameis Winston or J.J. McCarthy? Wink Martindale weighs in on what John Harbaugh might do for #Giants at QB Our Week 7 episode of “Wednesdays with Wink” is LIVE on the Talkin’ Ball with Pat Leonard @YouTube Channel 👀 Brought to you by @edge_marketsio SUBSCRIBE ✅
- Oct 21 Jordan Raanan (X) The #Giants didn't tell the players about a quarterback decision yesterday between Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy. They went over film from this past week's game. Would expect it to be addressed this morning at meetings. Practice at 1 pm.
-
Giants-Saints pregame thoughts:
• Finally, no rain! Will be nice to watch a game that isn't heavily impacted by the weather.
• The Giants were forced into the best version of their offense because they were trailing by two scores in the second half of last week's game. Don't want Jameis Winston dropping back 60 times every week, but the best players on this offense are Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely. The offense needs to run through them. If you have to live with a bad pick here and there, that's OK because Jameis is also delivering yards/touchdowns.
• Nabers saying he's only 80% back is encouraging considering he has 17 catches for 233 yards and two touchdowns in the past two games. That seems like an accurate assessment because he has left some plays on the field while being productive. This matchup should provide an opportunity for another big game.
• Have covered the RB shake-up plenty. Not much more to say. I don't get the Najee Harris love from the coaching staff, but this…
63 more updatesfrom 22 sources
- Oct 18 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) Maybe. Still think that’s asking a lot of J.J. McCarthy. Or the husk of Jameis Winston.
- Oct 18 Dan Duggan (X) Not sure I’ve ever seen mph for a QB in a game, but definitely matches the eye test (and reputation) · Quoting Doug Analytics: JJ McCarthy hit 50+ mph on 5/17 (29%) throws, including his fastest of 55.5 mph
- Oct 18 Greg Auman (X) And it's not just that J.J. McCarthy passed for 243 yards in a quarter -- he didn't get his first pass until 11:03 was left in the game, and he did it on 11 completions, with a 28-yard run mixed in there. And still lost.
- Oct 18 Albert Breer (X) J.J. McCarthy provided the Giants with a spark on Sunday, but @ConorOrr says John Harbaugh should play the long game and keep him on the bench for now
- Oct 18 Ian Rapoport (Bluesky) Giants QB J.J. McCarthy threw for 243 yards in the 4th quarter despite coming off the bench. It’s the most passing yards in a 4th quarter by any player this season and the 2nd-most passing yards in a 4th quarter by any QB who didn't start over the last 25 seasons.+1
- Oct 18 ESPN NFL News Giants' QB and RB situations left unsettled after home loss to Saints
- Oct 18 Dan Duggan (X) JJ McCarthy hit 50+ mph on 5/17 (29%) throws, including his fastest of 55.5 mph
- Oct 18 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) After J.J. McCarthy's near-heroics against the Saints on Sunday, who is the starting quarterback for the #NYGiants?
- Oct 18 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy's 243 yards is the second-most passing yards in a fourth quarter by a QB who didn't start over the past 25 seasons, per @ESPNStats. Only Sage Rosenfels (249) had more in Week 7 of 2007 for the Titans.
- Oct 18 Judy Battista (X) JJ McCarthy made an impression on the Giants in a critical area: he was able to move the offense without having had any practice reps with the starters, including the guys he was throwing to. That did not go unnoticed.
- Oct 18 Judy Battista (X) JJ McCarthy and Jameis Winston just shared a quick embrace in the locker room.
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) John Harbaugh on who his starting QB is next week: “I can’t answer that right now. It’s not up for conversation right now. Those things will be decided NOT 10 minutes after the game.” He says he has no problem with Jameis Winston and both QBs made plays, J.J. McCarthy played a heck of a game, but he’s not there yet #Giants
- Oct 18 Rotoworld Football (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy leads Giants in passing, rushing vs. Saints
- Oct 18 Pro Football Talk Saints survive J.J. McCarthy, Giants in 34-27 win+2
- Oct 18 Will Ragatz (X) The comeback fell just short, but what a final 11 minutes for J.J. McCarthy today. 243 passing yards on 11 completions 1 TD, 1 INT 26 rush yards Have to assume he starts next week for NYG.
- Oct 18 Dwain McFarland (X) Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely are feasting. Week 5 Nabers: 29.1 PPR points Likely: 32.4 Week 6 Nabers: 28.5 Likely: 23.9 How much do you trust JJ McCarthy going forward if named the starter (feels probable w/ Harbaugh connection)?
- Oct 18 Josina Anderson (X) The run that almost recovered a win for the #Giants. The longest scramble of J.J McCarthy ‘s career: Just came up short at the end running out of clock as Drew Brees eloquently explained with the situation that cost NYG 1:00 of time they needed in the final ticks of the game..
- Oct 18 Judy Battista (X) Giants lose but JJ McCarthy undeniably gave them a spark. Will be an interesting week.
- Oct 18 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Leonard] J.J. McCarthy completed 11 of 21 passes for 243 yards, 1 touchdown and 1 interception in the game’s final 11 minutes today. twitter.com/PLeonardNYDN... J.J. McCarthy also led the Giants in rushing with 2 carries for 26 yards.+1
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy also led the Giants in rushing with two carries for 26 yards. Read that again · Quoting Pat Leonard: J.J. McCarthy completed 11 of 21 passes for 243 yards, one touchdown and one interception in the game’s final 11 minutes today. The Giants scored 17 unanswered and nearly roared back from a 34-10 deficit
- Oct 18 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy threw for more yards (243) in 10:22 than Jameis Winston did (152) in more than three quarters in the Giants' loss to the Saints. Going to be a fascinating week in East Rutherford ...
- Oct 18 Jordan Raanan (X) Giants came up just short but J.J. McCarthy threw for 243 yards and led 3 scoring drives in the fourth quarter alone. Giants fall to 3-2-1. Saints 34, Giants 27
- Oct 18 David Furones (X) Valiant effort by JJ McCarthy to nearly lead that Giants comeback.
- Oct 18 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [NFL] J.J. McCarthy using his legs to get the first down!+1
- Oct 18 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) While I've been writing, JJ McCarthy and the #NYGiants have closed within 34-27 at the 2:00 warning.
- Oct 18 CBS Sports NFL Headlines Jameis Winston benched: Giants make move to J.J. McCarthy during Saints blowout
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) Is J.J. McCarthy going to do this? He just stepped up and launched a 46-yard completion to Malik Nabers. Giants only down 10 with under 3 minutes to play, ball inside the Saints' 30. Kellen Moore won't make it to Paris if the Giants do this
- Oct 18 Jordan Raanan (X) Great throw from J.J. McCarthy to Malik Nabers for a 46-yard gain. Giants in business again.
- Oct 18 Mike Garafolo (X) J.J. McCarthy shakes off the early pick and finds Isaiah Likely and somehow this is still at game at MetLife Stadium. The #Saints were probably halfway to Paris in their minds. Now have to find a way to finish.
- Oct 18 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [FOX Sports] J.J. McCarthy ➡️ Isaiah Likely to cut the lead
- Oct 18 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy throws his first TD as a Giant. Strike to Isaiah Likely for 24-yard TD. But 2-point conversion falls incomplete. Saints 34, Giants 24
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy with a dot to Isaiah Likely for a 24-yard TOUCHDOWN. Likely high points the ball and catches the TD. Giants going for two again. 34-24 with 506 to play right now
- Oct 18 rivers mccown (Bluesky) Common J.J. McCarthy completion
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) Hell of play by Charlie Jones to haul in that 49-yard pass from J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) Tyrone Tracy Jr. runs for a 5-yard TD, his second of the day. That's J.J. McCarthy's first TD drive as a Giants QB. McCarthy then hits Isaiah Likely for the two-point conversion, and its 34-18 Saints with 7 mins left
- Oct 18 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy's second drive ends in a TD. Tyrone Tracy runs for a 5-yard TD. Ends New Orleans' run of 34 unanswered points. Saints 34, Giants 18
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy delivers a downfield strike to Malik Nabers for a gain of 27 on the next drive · Quoting Pat Leonard: J.J. McCarthy intercepted. Still 10 minutes left in this one, unfortunately
- Oct 18 Will Ragatz (X) With the Giants getting blown out, J.J. McCarthy came into the game and threw a pick on his fourth pass.
- Oct 18 Pro Football Talk Giants put J.J. McCarthy in with Saints up 34-10 in fourth quarter
- Oct 18 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Saints] Martin Emerson picks off JJ McCarthy!
- Oct 18 Josina Anderson (X) 👀👀👀 · Quoting Pat Leonard: J.J. McCarthy intercepted. Still 10 minutes left in this one, unfortunately+1
- Oct 18 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) And, JJ McCarthy throws a pick to Martin Emerson. That ball was nowhere near an #NYGiants wide receiver.
- Oct 18 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy's first drive ends with ... an interception.
- Oct 18 Alec Lewis (X) 👀 · Quoting Dan Duggan: JJ McCarthy is in at QB
- Oct 18 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Terrell] JJ McCarthy has replaced Jameis Winston
- Oct 18 Mike Garafolo (X) J.J. McCarthy in at QB for the #Giants.
- Oct 18 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) JJ McCarthy at QB with the #NYGiants down 34-10 with 11:25 to play+2
- Oct 18 Judy Battista (X) JJ McCarthy is in for the Giants.
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) Cheers from the crowd that's left here at MetLife Stadium as J.J. McCarthy leads the Giants on for the next drive · Quoting Pat Leonard: Touchdown Shough to Chris Olave. I think we're about to see some J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 18 Jordan Raanan (X) It's J.J. McCarthy time. Let him run some of the offense. This is his preseason down 24 in the fourth quarter.
- Oct 18 Dan Duggan (X) JJ McCarthy is in at QB
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) Touchdown Shough to Chris Olave. I think we're about to see some J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 18 Denny Carter (Bluesky) Giants are turning JJ McCarthy into zoomer Taysom Hill · Quoting rivers mccown: It was important to put this on tape.
- Oct 18 Dan Duggan (X) Nice for Dominic Zvada to get a chip shot after last week's struggles. Not the smoothest drive there for the Giants. JJ McCarthy package doesn't produce (again).
- Oct 18 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy's first snap is a QB run that loses 2 yards. It's amazing that Jameis Winston continues to get this Giants offense into the end zone. They have absolutely no running game at all
- Oct 18 Dan Duggan (X) Giants-Saints pregame thoughts: • Finally, no rain! Will be nice to watch a game that isn't heavily impacted by the weather. • The Giants were forced into the best version of their offense because they were trailing by two scores in the second half of last week's game. Don't want Jameis Winston dropping back 60 times every week, but the best players on this offense are Malik Nabers and Isaiah Likely. The offense needs to run through them. If you have to live with a bad pick here and there, that's OK because Jameis is also delivering yards/touchdowns. • Nabers saying he's only 80% back is encouraging considering he has 17 catches for 233 yards and two touchdowns in the past two games. That seems like an accurate assessment because he has left some plays on the field while being productive. This matchup should provide an opportunity for another big game. • Have covered the RB shake-up plenty. Not much more to say. I don't get the Najee Harris love from the coaching staff, but this…
-
J.J. McCarthy officially is today’s No. 2 Giants QB behind Jameis Winston here at Washington
Giants inactives: RB Devin Singletary, OL J.C. Davis, DL Bobby Jamison-Travis, S Jason Pinnock (concussion), CB Nikko Reed, QB Jake Haener (3rd QB)
25 more updatesfrom 12 sources
- Oct 11 Jordan Raanan (X) The J.J. McCarthy package hasn't been overly productive.
- Oct 11 Pat Leonard (X) Here comes J.J. McCarthy's 5th snap and his 1st in the red zone. A handoff to Tyrone Tracy Jr. that gets stopped on the outside
- Oct 11 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy's fourth snap is a scramble for 2 yards Right tackle Jermaine Eluemunor is down
- Oct 11 Denny Carter (Bluesky) McCarthy will say “Joe Biden was sworn into office.” · Quoting Zachary Krueger: John Harbaugh is about to ask J.J. McCarthy who won the 2020 election. If he answers correctly, he'll come out to start in the second half.
- Oct 11 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy tries to keep after a fake jet sweep on third down. Gets stuffed. Giants settle for a 56-yard FG by Dominic Zvada. Commanders 12, Giants 6
- Oct 11 Tashan Reed (Bluesky) The Giants tried a J.J. McCarthy zone read for some reason. Frankie Luvu blew it up. #Commanders hold NY to a FG and lead 12-6.
- Oct 11 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) JJ McCarthy stuffed on a 3rd and 2 keeper. 4th down. Zvada 56-yard FG attempt. Drills it.
- Oct 11 Nicki Jhabvala (X) Frankie Luvu just crushed JJ McCarthy. Goodness.
- Oct 11 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy's third snap now here on 3rd and 2: A read option. McCarthy keeps it and gets tackled down hard by Frankie Luvu
- Oct 11 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) That was a screen thrown by JJ McCarthy
- Oct 11 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy's second snap of the game is a quick completion to Malik Nabers. But there is a flag down. Illegal shift on Isaiah Likely and Darnell Mooney. Likely has 3 penalties today
- Oct 11 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) No one would blame John Harbaugh for thinking about going to J.J. McCarthy at halftime.
- Oct 11 Pro Football Talk Giants put J.J. McCarthy in for one play
- Oct 11 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy just took his first snap as a Giant. A pop pass to Darnell Mooney. Came in on a 1st down after Jameis Winston hit Isaiah Likely for a 3rd down conversion. McCarthy plays one snap, then goes back out. Winston back in · Quoting Pat Leonard: J.J. McCarthy is in
- Oct 11 Dan Duggan (X) Darnell Mooney is down after a nasty face-mask penalty. Giants slipped JJ McCarthy in for his first snap on that play.
- Oct 11 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy gets in for a running play. Giants have a package for him. Jameis Winston comes in immediately after the play.
- Oct 11 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy is in
- Oct 11 Mike Garafolo (X) The #Giants opt to go with 2 active QBs and J.J. McCarthy as the primary backup to Jameis Winston today. · Quoting Jordan Raanan: J.J. McCarthy is the Giants backup QB. Giants inactives: S Jason Pinnock (concussion) RB Devin Singletary CB Nikko Reed DT Bobby Jamison-Travis OT J.C. Davis QB Jake Haener (3rd QB)
- Oct 11 Dan Duggan (X) These are the inactives 👇 This means JJ McCarthy is QB2. Haener can only play if both QBs ahead of him leave with injuries · Quoting Dan Duggan: QB Jake Haener (emergency QB) RB Devin Singletary OL JC Davis DL Bobby Jamison-Travis CB Nikko Reed S Jason Pinnock
- Oct 11 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy officially is today’s No. 2 Giants QB behind Jameis Winston here at Washington Giants inactives: RB Devin Singletary, OL J.C. Davis, DL Bobby Jamison-Travis, S Jason Pinnock (concussion), CB Nikko Reed, QB Jake Haener (3rd QB)
- Oct 11 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy is the Giants backup QB. Giants inactives: S Jason Pinnock (concussion) RB Devin Singletary CB Nikko Reed DT Bobby Jamison-Travis OT J.C. Davis QB Jake Haener (3rd QB)
- Oct 11 Zack Rosenblatt (X) Interesting guy · Quoting Connor Hughes: Tarp starting to come off. First player on field for #Giants: JJ McCarthy “What a day!” he gleefully said as he walked on field+1
- Oct 11 Zack Rosenblatt (X) Tarp starting to come off. First player on field for #Giants: JJ McCarthy “What a day!” he gleefully said as he walked on field
- Oct 11 Dan Duggan (X) Giants-Commanders (obviously watching the game while I type this!) pregame thoughts: • Would expect a ground-heavy game plan in these conditions. Probably going to call on more of a game manager performance from Jameis Winston. I remain intrigued by the idea of a JJ McCarthy package. He's more mobile than Winston, but I don't view him as some huge run threat. Maybe they insert him in the red zone if the offense is struggling. • The Commanders run defense has been solid, but the Giants need to find a way to generate some explosives. I think reintegrating Tyrone Tracy is the best route to that, but not expecting a huge uptick in his usage. Think we'll continue to see more of Najee Harris. Wouldn't be surprised by some jumbo packages, especially with the lack of WR depth. • Malik Nabers wasn't happy with his lack of targets in the second half of last week's game. This is a favorable matchup for Nabers, but the weather may limit his opportunities. Interested to see how they manage…
- Oct 11 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) I would expect we will see the J.J. McCarthy package at some point today, perhaps in the red zone where the QB run could be impactful.
-
Maybe I’m wrong but why is ricard on the field for 24% of plays ? · Quoting Dan Duggan: Apologies for the delay in the snap counts breakdown, but kids were off from school yesterday and puppy decided to snack on a sock so there was a fun emergency vet visit. Anyway, here are the Giants' offensive snap counts vs. the Commanders:
• I've never been a fan of rotating QBs. Even for all those years in New Orleans, I'm not sure taking one of the best QBs ever off the field for Taysom Hill was a smart strategy. And JJ McCarthy isn't Hill as a runner. They had a ton of confusion before one snap deep in the red zone (a 1-yard Tyrone Tracy run) and then Jameis Winston had a delay of game on the next play after shuttling back in at QB. The negatives outweigh the positives with the rotation. If you want to play McCarthy (eventually), just play him. Until then, let Winston be the QB.
• They're in a tough spot at RB. Cam Skattebo is their best back, but he hasn't been effective this season (3.6…
1 more updatefrom 1 source
- Oct 13 Dan Duggan (X) Maybe I’m wrong but why is ricard on the field for 24% of plays ? · Quoting Dan Duggan: Apologies for the delay in the snap counts breakdown, but kids were off from school yesterday and puppy decided to snack on a sock so there was a fun emergency vet visit. Anyway, here are the Giants' offensive snap counts vs. the Commanders: • I've never been a fan of rotating QBs. Even for all those years in New Orleans, I'm not sure taking one of the best QBs ever off the field for Taysom Hill was a smart strategy. And JJ McCarthy isn't Hill as a runner. They had a ton of confusion before one snap deep in the red zone (a 1-yard Tyrone Tracy run) and then Jameis Winston had a delay of game on the next play after shuttling back in at QB. The negatives outweigh the positives with the rotation. If you want to play McCarthy (eventually), just play him. Until then, let Winston be the QB. • They're in a tough spot at RB. Cam Skattebo is their best back, but he hasn't been effective this season (3.6…
- Oct 13 Dan Duggan (X) Apologies for the delay in the snap counts breakdown, but kids were off from school yesterday and puppy decided to snack on a sock so there was a fun emergency vet visit. Anyway, here are the Giants' offensive snap counts vs. the Commanders: • I've never been a fan of rotating QBs. Even for all those years in New Orleans, I'm not sure taking one of the best QBs ever off the field for Taysom Hill was a smart strategy. And JJ McCarthy isn't Hill as a runner. They had a ton of confusion before one snap deep in the red zone (a 1-yard Tyrone Tracy run) and then Jameis Winston had a delay of game on the next play after shuttling back in at QB. The negatives outweigh the positives with the rotation. If you want to play McCarthy (eventually), just play him. Until then, let Winston be the QB. • They're in a tough spot at RB. Cam Skattebo is their best back, but he hasn't been effective this season (3.6 ypc) and the fumbling issue is a real problem. Tracy has had more NFL production and he…
-
Jake Haener takes the roster spot of Braxton Berrios, who is out for the season with a foot injury. · Quoting Mike Garafolo: The #Giants are signing QB Jake Haener to their 53-man roster off their practice squad, sources say. He joins J.J. McCarthy on the active roster behind Jameis Winston.
6 more updatesfrom 6 sources
- Oct 7 Pat Leonard (X) A lot of updates from Giants practice viewing period: Malik Nabers did not participate in routes on air. He walked over to the trainers/return to play team and sat down on a medicine ball J.J. McCarthy (in video) snapping as QB2 behind Jameis Winston in individuals. Cam Skattebo wearing a red (non-contact?) pinnie Bryan Hudson snapping as the top center No LT Andrew Thomas, DL Chauncey Golston, RB Najee Harris or S Jason Pinnock Jake Haener now signed to active roster as QB3
- Oct 7 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) Trades over the last 10 days: 🏈JJ McCarthy to the Giants 🏈Joey Porter Jr. to the Cowboys 🏈Cam Jurgens to the Ravens Trade deadline is Nov. 10. ⏰+1
- Oct 7 Dan Duggan (X) This will enable them to activate all three QBs again, although more likely that McCarthy takes over as QB2 soon and Haener becomes the emergency third QB · Quoting Mike Garafolo: The #Giants are signing QB Jake Haener to their 53-man roster off their practice squad, sources say. He joins J.J. McCarthy on the active roster behind Jameis Winston.
- Oct 7 Jordan Raanan (X) Jake Haener takes the roster spot of Braxton Berrios, who is out for the season with a foot injury. · Quoting Mike Garafolo: The #Giants are signing QB Jake Haener to their 53-man roster off their practice squad, sources say. He joins J.J. McCarthy on the active roster behind Jameis Winston.
- Oct 7 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) From J.J. McCarthy to the Center Spot: Giants Storylines Heading Into Week 5
- Oct 7 Mike Garafolo (X) The #Giants are signing QB Jake Haener to their 53-man roster off their practice squad, sources say. He joins J.J. McCarthy on the active roster behind Jameis Winston.
-
Trade! The Vikings are sending QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick, sources tell @ringer @netflixsports.
With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, New York adds another young QB, while Minnesota gains flexibility and McCarthy gets a fresh start.
124 more updatesfrom 48 sources
- Sep 28 Dan Duggan (X) I agree with the Week 9 votes. That assumes Jameis looks somewhat better over the next week or two · Quoting Dan Duggan: When does JJ McCarthy make this first start for the Giants?
- Sep 28 Albert Breer (X) I missed the late Dwayne Haskins, so that makes eight on the second list. For those interested, the last QB to not make it three years with his drafting team before Tebow was Cade McNown. · Quoting Albert Breer: So this is interesting ... • From 2000-09, every first-round QB made it thru three seasons with the team that drafted him. • From 2010-24, seven (Tim Tebow, Brandon Weeden, Johnny Manziel, Josh Rosen, Trey Lance, Kenny Pickett, JJ McCarthy) haven't. Seems pretty relevant.
- Sep 28 Alec Lewis (X) The J.J. McCarthy Vikings era offers many lessons. But maybe the most important? The one that covers both quarterbacks and organizations? When you draft a QB, you’re rolling the dice, convictions about system or prospect be damned
- Sep 28 Dan Duggan (X) When does JJ McCarthy make this first start for the Giants?
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) You know the quote. "I believe that organizations fail young quarterbacks before young quarterbacks fail organizations." KOC was asked about it today (s/o @ChrisLongKSTP), in the wake of the J.J. McCarthy trade. I wrote about it
- Sep 28 Vikings Team Site Takeaways: Kevin O'Connell & Nolan Teasley Discuss J.J. McCarthy Trade
- Sep 28 Dan Duggan (X) Since everyone agreed with my take on the JJ McCarthy trade in video from, I wrote a column on it
- Sep 28 Aaron Wilson (X) #Giants waived Jake Haener after J.J. McCarthy trade+2
- Sep 28 Dan Duggan (X) The expectation is that Haener will re-sign with the Giants' practice squad. Harbaugh said it's TBD if Haener or JJ McCarthy will be QB2 on Sunday. Unless I'm mistaken, if Haener is elevated from the practice squad, I think he has to be QB2 and McCarthy can be the emergency QB because he's on the 53. That approach probably makes sense anyway since McCarthy isn't going to have much time to learn a complex offense · Quoting Tom Pelissero: After acquiring J.J. McCarthy in a trade, the Giants have waived QB Jake Haener.
- Sep 28 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) Per the NFL transactions report, the #NYGiants have waived QB Jake Haener after acquiring J.J. McCarthy.
- Sep 28 Jacob Westendorf (X) no man will ever love you the way a michigan man loves jj mccarthy
- Sep 28 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) John Harbaugh won't guess on when, or if, J.J. McCarthy will replace Jameis Winston as #NYGiants quarterback.
- Sep 28 ESPN NFL News J.J. McCarthy isn't the answer for the Giants ... right? Barnwell on the trade's potential impact
- Sep 28 Dan Duggan (X) Harbaugh on giving up an asset for JJ McCarthy: “You need another quarterback in our situation and you wanted to go get the very best quarterback you could get, which is what we did. That’s the thinking. Anything else beyond that, I’m not really comprehending the question, I guess. But that’s it. That’s very simple.”
- Sep 28 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants Trade for J.J. McCarthy: Winners and Losers From the Deal
- Sep 28 Giants Team Site Giants acquire QB J.J. McCarthy from Vikings in exchange for 2027 draft pick+3
- Sep 28 Pro Football Talk John Harbaugh on J.J. McCarthy: Really happy to add a strong, young quarterback
- Sep 28 Mike Garafolo (X) Harbaugh says McCarthy will be QB2 or 3 vs. the #AZCardinals “All the other conversation isn’t going to help us beat the Cardinals. So it’s irrelevant. Jameis will be the starter for as long as I can see into the future.” · Quoting Mike Garafolo: #Giants HC John Harbaugh calls JJ McCarthy “a strong young quarterback. He has some experience in the National Football League.” Says he’s “going to make us a stronger football team.” Harbaugh stands by Jameis Winston as his starter, says he did what they needed to win Sunday.
- Sep 28 Ian Rapoport (Bluesky) A fun trade: The New York Giants acquire JJ McCarthy.+1
- Sep 28 Bo Brack (X) Cardinals facing Jameis Winston in Week 4 · Quoting Mike Garafolo: #Giants HC John Harbaugh calls JJ McCarthy “a strong young quarterback. He has some experience in the National Football League.” Says he’s “going to make us a stronger football team.” Harbaugh stands by Jameis Winston as his starter, says he did what they needed to win Sunday.
- Sep 28 Bo Brack (X) #Giants HC John Harbaugh calls JJ McCarthy “a strong young quarterback. He has some experience in the National Football League.” Says he’s “going to make us a stronger football team.” Harbaugh stands by Jameis Winston as his starter, says he did what they needed to win Sunday.
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) Kevin O’Connell on J.J. McCarthy: "Sometimes things don't work out how you envisioned or how you planned or how you hoped." "I believe in the collective work that was put in. I believe in J.J. and the intent and the work that he put in. This is just where we are today."
- Sep 28 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) The Vikings couldn’t wait to get rid of JJ McCarthy. Remarkable to watch a team so completely abandon a QB they invested so much in.
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) Kevin O’Connell on the J.J. McCarthy trade: "Today's a tough day. Nothing about this changes the way I feel about J.J. or the hopes I have for him. I think it's a good opportunity in New York. As I told him, I'll be pulling for him like crazy, to see him go and do well and apply a lot of the things that we've talked about over his period of time here."
- Sep 28 Pro Football Talk Vikings GM Nolan Teasley: J.J. McCarthy trade was the best decision for the Vikings
- Sep 28 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) Vikings coach Kevin O’Connell said he spent some time with J.J. McCarthy this morning, “which was emotional. “Our relationship means a lot to me. I believe it means a lot to him, and I was just really thankful to have that time one-on-one with him.”+1
- Sep 28 Jeremy Fowler (X) Vikings GM Nolan Teasley speaks on the J.J. McCarthy trade. · Quoting Minnesota Vikings: "I think he was an important person to this organization. I enjoyed my time getting to know J.J., I want the best for him, and I hope that he succeeds in the future." - GM Nolan Teasley
- Sep 28 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) Vikings GM Nolan Teasley just wrapped up discussing the J.J. McCarthy trade with reporters. He said “there’s been a lot of inquiries” on McCarthy, “and then just recently it came together.” The Vikings had put together trade comps that made them feel McCarthy was worth a fifth-rounder, he said.
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) Nolan Teasley called the 5th-round pick the Vikings acquired for J.J. McCarthy "an asset that, in all honesty, is gonna help us in the future or it could help us this season. We don't know." "This season and this roster is gonna constantly evolve. Today's another example of that."
- Sep 28 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) One thing that has been made clear by the J.J. McCarthy trade. #NYGiants coach John Harbaugh cares about the NOW. He'll worry about the future in the future. Whatever it takes to make the Giants the best they can be right now is what will be done.
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) Nolan Teasley on the Vikings' trade of J.J. McCarthy: "We have as an organization, and me personally, there's a responsibility to make decisions that we believe are in the best interest of the organization, of the Vikings holistically. Sometimes those decisions aren't easy."
- Sep 28 Alec Lewis (X) Vikings GM Nolan Teasley on the J.J. McCarthy trade: "We have a responsibility to make decisions that we believe are in the best interest of the organization. Sometimes, those decisions aren't easy."
- Sep 28 Andrew Krammer (Bluesky) The McCarthy era ends after 10 starts · Quoting Ben Goessling: The #Vikings traded J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a fifth-round pick, pending a physical.
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) The J.J. McCarthy experience in Minnesota was a wild ride. I put together a timeline recapping the whole thing (or at least most of it), from the day he was drafted to today's trade, 29 months later.
- Sep 28 Mina Kimes (Bluesky) Giants GM lurking on Bluesky confirmed · Quoting Mina Kimes: Floating a lil trial balloon of an idea here: What if the Vikings traded JJ McCarthy to the Giants
- Sep 28 Albert Breer (X) So this is interesting ... • From 2000-09, every first-round QB made it thru three seasons with the team that drafted him. • From 2010-24, seven (Tim Tebow, Brandon Weeden, Johnny Manziel, Josh Rosen, Trey Lance, Kenny Pickett, JJ McCarthy) haven't. Seems pretty relevant.
- Sep 28 ESPN NFL News Grading NFL trades: Who won the J.J. McCarthy deal, Giants or Vikings?
- Sep 28 Dan Duggan (X) This was my live reaction to the McCarthy news. Much more to come… · Quoting SNY Giants: "I just think this is a desperate move. I don't really see even the upside in it. I don't think he's a good quarterback. Is he going to come in here, learn the offense, take over for Jameis, and then lead this team... to what? To where?" @DDuggan21 on the J.J. McCarthy trade
- Sep 28 John Sigler (Bluesky) Minnesota Vikings draft bust J.J. McCarthy is going to the New York Giants, with former New Orleans Saints QB Jake Haener waived in a corresponding move.
- Sep 28 CBS Sports NFL Headlines J.J. McCarthy experiment unraveled after only 10 starts in Minnesota; can QB pick up the pieces with Giants?
- Sep 28 Jordan Schultz (X) The #Giants reached out to the #Vikings last week about JJ McCarthy, I’m told. The idea of adding him was to bolster the QB room since the season is still so young. Jameis Winston remains QB1. · Quoting Jordan Schultz: BREAKING: The Vikings are trading QB JJ McCarthy to the Giants, per sources.
- Sep 28 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy started 18 fewer games at quarterback for the #Vikings than any other first-round pick in franchise history. Teddy Bridgewater, whose catastrophic knee injury ended his time as the starter before his third season, is next on the list (data from Pro Football Reference)
- Sep 28 Mike Garafolo (X) The financials for the #Giants: Just under $1m for McCarthy this season. Next year, they’re on the hook for $3.775m fully guaranteed. They owe Jameis Winston just over $6m fully guaranteed in 2027 as part of his new deal. · Quoting Mike Garafolo: The question about J.J. McCarthy coming into the Draft was about him coming from a run-oriented offense into the pass-heavy NFL. This #Giants offense is more in line with what he ran in college. John Harbaugh & Co. also talked about adding a QB who can move. That’s McCarthy.
- Sep 28 CBS Sports NFL Headlines J.J. McCarthy trade grades: QB could be a downgrade for Giants, Vikings get a clean split
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) I have a lot of respect for the way J.J. McCarthy remained a great teammate this year after his demotion to QB3. He went through a lot in his time with the Vikings.
- Sep 28 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants secure QB J.J. McCarthy in trade. Mobility brings RPO potential back to the offense after a sluggish showing. #NFL #Giants #JJMcCarthy #Quarterback #Football #Trade #SportsNews #NYGiants #NFLTrade
- Sep 28 FTN (Bluesky) Maybe all JJ McCarthy needs is a Harbaugh 🤔
- Sep 28 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) The Giants trade a fifth-round pick to the Vikings for JJ McCarthy: Instant thoughts, including one scout’s skepticism the trade will move the needle … youtu.be/SAiAYONrooc+4
- Sep 28 Albert Breer (X) The Giants and Vikings tried like hell to trade into the third pick to get Drake Maye in 2024. The Giants then decided to punt on the QB class. The Vikings took JJ McCarthy. And now McCarthy is traded from one to the other. Drafting QBs—not a perfect science.
- Sep 28 CBS Sports NFL Headlines NFL Week 3 winners and losers, plus J.J. McCarthy dealt to Giants and Eagles-Bears picks for Monday night
- Sep 28 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Seifert] According to the Elias Sports Bureau, J.J. McCarthy is 1 of 4 first-round QBs in the past 25 years to start 10 or fewer games for the team that drafted them. The others: Paxton Lynch Trey Lance Johnny Manziel
- Sep 28 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) The Sunday Aftermath. Breaking down the league-wide injury apocalypse, changing running back situations, J.J. McCarthy's trade and much more in my Week 3 recap
- Sep 28 Bleeding Green Nation (PHI) J.J. McCarthy joins the NFC East
- Sep 28 Yahoo Fantasy Football Sunday Aftermath: Week 3 injury apocalypse, J.J. McCarthy's trade, and much more
- Sep 28 CBS Sports NFL Headlines J.J. McCarthy trade: Giants acquire Vikings QB in wake of Jaxon Dart injury
- Sep 28 Greg Auman (X) A fifth-round pick feels like good value for Giants. Basically two years and $6 million left for McCarthy, and if he gets any kind of contract to leave in two years, they get a comparable pick back as a comp pick. · Quoting Jay Glazer: Scoopage: The Vikings have agreed to a trade with the New York Giants. Vikings receive 2027 5th-round pick and Giants receive QB JJ McCarthy. @NFLonFOX
- Sep 28 Alec Lewis (X) Will have A LOT more to come on the J.J. McCarthy trade this afternoon and throughout the week. Initial reaction from execs and coaches throughout the league is that this was long expected, going all the way back to the end of last season. Has been a topsy-turvy ride, to put it lightly.
- Sep 28 Judy Battista (X) John Harbaugh said yesterday Jameis Winston will start Sunday vs. Ariz. After that, how fast can JJ McCarthy get up to speed & does he give them better chance to win than Winston at that point? Clear message: despite injuries to Dart and Burns, Harbaugh not giving up on 2026.
- Sep 28 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) The Giants had a chance to take JJ McCarthy in the 2024 NFL Draft but selected Malik Nabers at No. 6. Two years later, McCarthy lands in New York, joining Jameis Winston in the Giants’ QB room.+1
- Sep 28 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) Terms: Vikings receive 2027 5th-round pick and Giants receive QB JJ McCarthy.+2
- Sep 28 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) JJ McCarthy was coached by Jim Harbaugh at Michigan and now will be coached by John Harbaugh in the NFL with the Giants.+1
- Sep 28 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) Trade: Vikings are sending J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants, sources me, @rapsheet and @mikegarafolo.+2
- Sep 28 NFL Daily News (Bluesky) Schultz: Addition of JJ McCarthy viewed as move to bolster backup QB position behind Jameis Winston. · Quoting NFL Daily News: ‼️ Trade summary, per Tom Pelissero: Giants get - JJ McCarthy Vikings get - 2027 5th-round pick+1
- Sep 28 FTN (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy gets a fresh start with the Giants... but is there any actual fantasy value here? @danieltkelley.bsky.social breaks down the trade & the John Harbaugh connection ⤵️
- Sep 28 Jeremy Fowler (X) Rival teams believed McCarthy would be available at a reasonable cost because the Vikings clearly had moved on. A fifth-rounder feels like a sweet spot. · Quoting Ian Rapoport: Full terms: #Vikings receive 2027 5th-round pick and Giants receive QB JJ McCarthy.
- Sep 28 Mike Garafolo (X) The question about J.J. McCarthy coming into the Draft was about him coming from a run-oriented offense into the pass-heavy NFL. This #Giants offense is more in line with what he ran in college. John Harbaugh & Co. also talked about adding a QB who can move. That’s McCarthy.
- Sep 28 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) Early story on the Vikings trading J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a fifth-round pick. Plenty of updates coming to this later today
- Sep 28 Albert Breer (X) Giants coach John Harbaugh obviously has good background on JJ McCarthy from his brother—even got to see a few of McCarthy’s games at Michigan from the sideline. Still just 23, McCarthy will come in to back up Jameis Winston initially, and we’ll see where it goes from there.
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) J.J. McCarthy's time with the Vikings was a wild ride. The lost rookie season. The ups and (mostly) downs of last year while probably playing before he was ready. The "QB competition" this year, then demotion to QB3. A fresh start for both sides makes sense, I think. I'll be fascinated to see what he looks like with the Giants if/when he sees the field. More of an unknown than Jameis, certainly. Vikings move forward with Murray/Wentz/Brosmer and have a lot of work to do on offense. Depending on how this year goes, they could be back in the QB draft mix next spring.
- Sep 28 Albert Breer (X) Whoa, he’s already a captain??? · Quoting SportsCenter: A new beginning for J.J. McCarthy 🗽+1
- Sep 28 Jacob Westendorf (X) The last time a Harbaugh coached McCarthy, it worked pretty well. · Quoting Blue By 90: BREAKING: JJ McCarthy has been traded to the New York Giants.
- Sep 28 Jeremy Fowler (X) This is significant for a lot of reasons, but perhaps most notable: Giants did a lot of homework on 2024 QB draft class and clearly liked McCarthy. Plus, the Harbaugh connection helps. Fresh start for a player who needed it. · Quoting Adam Schefter: Trade: Vikings are sending J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants, sources me, @rapsheet and @mikegarafolo.
- Sep 28 Andrew Siciliano (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy is the second 2024 1st rounder to be traded. McCarthy went 10th overall. Vikings get a 2027 5th round pick. Jared Verse went 19th overall. Rams sent Verse, a #1, #2, and #3 for Myles Garrett.
- Sep 28 Jacob Westendorf (X) BREAKING: JJ McCarthy has been traded to the New York Giants.
- Sep 28 John Shipley (X) Quoting Adam Schefter: Trade: Vikings are sending J.J. McCarthy to the New York Giants, sources me, @rapsheet and @mikegarafolo.
- Sep 28 Albert Breer (X) The Giants are sending a 2027 fifth-round pick to the Vikings for JJ McCarthy, per sources. They have an extra sixth-rounder already, from the Daniel Faalele trade. · Quoting Ian Rapoport: 🚨 🚨 🚨 The #Giants are trading for #Vikings former first-round QB JJ McCarthy, per me, @AdamSchefter and @MikeGarafolo. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, NYG acquires McCarthy to help solidify their room. An intriguing add.+2
- Sep 28 Dan Duggan (X) "I just think this is a desperate move. I don't really see even the upside in it. I don't think he's a good quarterback. Is he going to come in here, learn the offense, take over for Jameis, and then lead this team... to what? To where?" @DDuggan21 on the J.J. McCarthy trade
- Sep 28 Denny Carter (Bluesky) I guess this makes sense for both sides. Winston clearly doesn't even want to be out there anymore and coaches seem to think McCarthy is good even though he's never been good. · Quoting Tom Pelissero: Trade! The Vikings are sending QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick, sources tell The Ringer and Netflix Sports. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, New York adds another young QB, while Minnesota gains flexibility and McCarthy gets a fresh start.
- Sep 28 Jordan Schultz (X) JJ McCarthy heads to the #Giants to play for John Harbaugh, after having won a national title for his brother Jim, at Michigan. · Quoting Jordan Schultz: BREAKING: The Vikings are trading QB JJ McCarthy to the Giants, per sources.
- Sep 28 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) The Vikings very clearly couldn’t wait to get rid of J.J. McCarthy, and get a 5th round pick for him, according to Adam Schefter. Meanwhile, the Giants desperately needed options at the position off Jameis Winston’s performance against the Titans.
- Sep 28 Alec Lewis (X) The Vikings are clearing approximately $3.7 million for 2027 after the trade, per source. Team projected to have potentially 10 draft picks for '27, factoring in potential compensatory selection. · Quoting Alec Lewis: The Vikings are trading QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants, per sources. It's for a fifth-round pick.
- Sep 28 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) The Giants are trading for J.J. McCarthy, ESPN’s Adam Schefter reports.
- Sep 28 Bo Brack (X) Cardinals still likely to face Jameis Winston in Week 4. Giants held to 6 field goals in two games with Winston in the lineup. Jameis less than 120 passing yards in both games · Quoting Ian Rapoport: 🚨 🚨 🚨 The #Giants are trading for #Vikings former first-round QB JJ McCarthy, per me, @AdamSchefter and @MikeGarafolo. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, NYG acquires McCarthy to help solidify their room. An intriguing add.
- Sep 28 rivers mccown (Bluesky) I feel bad for our biggest media market but this is tremendous content · Quoting Tom Pelissero: Trade! The Vikings are sending QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick, sources tell The Ringer and Netflix Sports. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, New York adds another young QB, while Minnesota gains flexibility and McCarthy gets a fresh start.
- Sep 28 Jason B. Hirschhorn (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy skipped town before @arif.bsky.social could prove that Jim Harbaugh was behind his AI-generated propaganda website. Shrewd move, honestly. · Quoting Jason B. Hirschhorn: RIP StartNine.win
- Sep 28 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Breaking: The Giants are trading for Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy. The cost: a 2027 fifth rounder. (Photo: Matt Pendleton-Imagn Images)
- Sep 28 Tom Pelissero (Bluesky) By trading J.J. McCarthy now, the Vikings save over $4.6M in cash and cap space and get an unconditional fifth-round pick in the next draft that, depending how the Giants finish, could end up being a top-150 selection. Meanwhile, New York adds another former first-round pick QB. · Quoting Tom Pelissero: Trade! The Vikings are sending QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick, sources tell The Ringer and Netflix Sports. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, New York adds another young QB, while Minnesota gains flexibility and McCarthy gets a fresh start.
- Sep 28 Mike Kaye (X) Kinda wild value (or lack thereof) when you consider what the previous Vikings GM gave up for half a season of Adam Thielen. · Quoting Ian Rapoport: Full terms: #Vikings receive 2027 5th-round pick and Giants receive QB JJ McCarthy.
- Sep 28 Zack Rosenblatt (X) One of the funniest QB rooms ever. · Quoting Jonathan Jones: The Vikings are trading former franchise QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round selection, source tells @TheAthletic. McCarthy finds a new home as Big Blue goes forward this week with Jameis Winston at QB in Jaxson Dart's absence.
- Sep 28 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) The #Vikings traded J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a fifth-round pick, pending a physical.
- Sep 28 Alec Lewis (X) The trade is pending physical, per sources. If you've followed for months, you knew this was the likely outcome. The Vikings held off from worse offers, ended up taking the fifth-round offer. · Quoting Alec Lewis: The Vikings are trading QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants, per sources. It's for a fifth-round pick.
- Sep 28 Dwain McFarland (X) JJ MCCARTHY IS HEADING TO THE GIANTS 🚨
- Sep 28 Tom Pelissero (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy is a Giant. Full breakdown in The Sweep
- Sep 28 Jordan Schultz (X) Comp update: The #Vikings will receive a 2027 5th-round pick in exchange for JJ McCarthy, per source. · Quoting Jordan Schultz: BREAKING: The Vikings are trading QB JJ McCarthy to the Giants, per sources.
- Sep 28 Zac Stevens (X) Bo Nix leads the NFL in 4th quarter comebacks and game-winning drives since he was the 12th pick in the draft in 2024. J.J. McCarthy was picked one spot ahead of Bo and was just traded for a 5th-round pick. · Quoting Tom Pelissero: Trade! The Vikings are sending QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick, sources tell @ringer @netflixsports. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, New York adds another young QB, while Minnesota gains flexibility and McCarthy gets a fresh start.
- Sep 28 Will Ragatz (X) The J.J. McCarthy era in Minnesota is over. He's being traded to the New York Giants for a fifth-round pick. McCarthy, the former No. 10 pick, played 10 games for the Vikings in two-plus seasons. · Quoting Tom Pelissero: Trade! The Vikings are sending QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick, sources tell @ringer @netflixsports. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, New York adds another young QB, while Minnesota gains flexibility and McCarthy gets a fresh start.
- Sep 28 Zack Rosenblatt (X) The Vikings are trading former franchise QB J.J. McCarthy to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round selection, source tells @TheAthletic. McCarthy finds a new home as Big Blue goes forward this week with Jameis Winston at QB in Jaxson Dart's absence.
- Sep 28 Mary Kay Cabot (X) Some #Giants QB news. #Browns play there Dec. 20! · Quoting Ian Rapoport: 🚨 🚨 🚨 The #Giants are trading for #Vikings former first-round QB JJ McCarthy, per me, @AdamSchefter and @MikeGarafolo. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, NYG acquires McCarthy to help solidify their room. An intriguing add.
- Sep 28 NFL Daily News (Bluesky) ‼️ Trade summary, per Tom Pelissero: Giants get - JJ McCarthy Vikings get - 2027 5th-round pick
- Sep 28 Jordan Schultz (X) BREAKING: The Vikings are trading QB JJ McCarthy to the Giants, per sources.
- Sep 28 Greg Auman (X) Giants won on four field goals Sunday, but this gives them another option beyond Jameis Winston. · Quoting Ian Rapoport: 🚨 🚨 🚨 The #Giants are trading for #Vikings former first-round QB JJ McCarthy, per me, @AdamSchefter and @MikeGarafolo. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, NYG acquires McCarthy to help solidify their room. An intriguing add.
- Sep 28 Mike Garafolo (X) One QB added for the #Giants. · Quoting Ian Rapoport: 🚨 🚨 🚨 The #Giants are trading for #Vikings former first-round QB JJ McCarthy, per me, @AdamSchefter and @MikeGarafolo. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, NYG acquires McCarthy to help solidify their room. An intriguing add.
- Sep 28 Greg Auman (X) 🚨 🚨 🚨 The #Giants are trading for #Vikings former first-round QB JJ McCarthy, per me, @AdamSchefter and @MikeGarafolo. With Jaxson Dart out for the regular season, NYG acquires McCarthy to help solidify their room. An intriguing add.
- Sep 28 Jay Glazer (X) Scoopage: The Vikings have agreed to a trade with the New York Giants. Vikings receive 2027 5th-round pick and Giants receive QB JJ McCarthy. @NFLonFOX
-
J.J. McCarthy is active. Not the emergency third-string QB.
Ar'Darius Washington, Jihad Ward and Devin Singletary inactive. Washington hasn't worked out so far.
Giants inactives:
S Ar’Darius Washington
RB Devin Singletary
CB Nikko Reed
DL Jihad Ward
OL J.C. Davis
TE Thomas Fidone
DT Bobby Jamison-Travis
18 more updatesfrom 8 sources
- Oct 4 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Why the Giants Had J.J. McCarthy Active Despite Less Than a Week in the Offense
- Oct 4 Jordan Raanan (X) The Giants had J.J. McCarthy active because if gave them "another option." They had certain plays prepared for him. John Harbaugh said they didn't come close to putting him into the game though.
- Oct 4 Judy Battista (X) John Harbaugh said JJ McCarthy was active to give the Giants the option of using him with a package of plays. They liked what they had for special teams, so had the roster spot. He was not ready to be the number two.
- Oct 4 Dan Duggan (X) A few postgame notes from Harbaugh: • JJ McCarthy was active to give them the option in case they wanted to put him in the game to run plays they had prepared for him. It was "unrealistic" to make McCarthy the No. 2 QB though, so Jake Haener was also active. • Harbaugh said the center change was based on John Michael Schmitz missing "a couple of days of practice" due to the birth of his child. Bryan Hudson had been practicing well enough that they wanted to work him in. Harbaugh said the change made sense based on the circumstances, but noted it's "not a long-term thing." He said they have two centers they really like.
- Oct 4 Dan Duggan (X) We may find out how ready JJ McCarthy is...
- Oct 4 Kyle Odegard (X) Jameis Winston stinks. JJ McCarthy gonna get his chance soon with the Giants.
- Oct 4 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) I doubt we see JJ McCarthy today, but rough start for the ‘no chance they sit Jameis’ faction of Giants fans …
- Oct 4 Pat Leonard (X) It looks Bryan Hudson is going to start at center for the Giants. That's how they're lining up in warmups · Quoting Pat Leonard: Just caught a segment of Giants warmups now with starting QB Jameis Winston taking snaps from Bryan Hudson while backup Jake Haener takes snaps from John Michael Schmidt Then they gave 3rd QB J.J. McCarthy a couple quick snaps with Hudson
- Oct 4 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy Is Active for Giants vs. Cardinals. Here's what that could mean for today's game.
- Oct 4 Pat Leonard (X) Just caught a segment of Giants warmups now with starting QB Jameis Winston taking snaps from Bryan Hudson while backup Jake Haener takes snaps from John Michael Schmidt Then they gave 3rd QB J.J. McCarthy a couple quick snaps with Hudson
- Oct 4 Jordan Raanan (X) This gives the Giants flexibility to use J.J. McCarthy in specific packages. Perhaps short yardage or goal line? Something to utilize his legs? · Quoting Jordan Raanan: J.J. McCarthy is active. Not the emergency third-string QB. Ar'Darius Washington, Jihad Ward and Devin Singletary inactive. Washington hasn't worked out so far. Giants inactives: S Ar’Darius Washington RB Devin Singletary CB Nikko Reed DL Jihad Ward OL J.C. Davis TE Thomas Fidone DT Bobby Jamison-Travis
- Oct 4 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy when asked how he is feeling physically: “Really good. Obviously not getting hit in a while, I feel really good. But I'm excited to feel a little sore the next day." · Quoting Pat Leonard: J.J. McCarthy sees “opportunity” with Giants after “shock” of Vikings trade
- Oct 4 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy is active. Not the emergency third-string QB. Ar'Darius Washington, Jihad Ward and Devin Singletary inactive. Washington hasn't worked out so far. Giants inactives: S Ar’Darius Washington RB Devin Singletary CB Nikko Reed DL Jihad Ward OL J.C. Davis TE Thomas Fidone DT Bobby Jamison-Travis
- Oct 4 Dan Duggan (X) Hmm, surprised Jihad Ward is inactive. And this means JJ McCarthy is just regular active, no emergency QB designation. He can enter the game at any point · Quoting Dan Salomone: GIANTS INACTIVES ▪️S Ar’Darius Washington ▪️RB Devin Singletary ▪️CB Nikko Reed ▪️OLB Jihad Ward ▪️OL J.C. Davis ▪️TE Thomas Fidone II ▪️DL Bobby Jamison-Travis CARDINALS INACTIVES ▪️QB Carson Beck (3rd QB) ▪️CB Starling Thomas V ▪️S Dadrion Taylor-Demerson ▪️LB Cameron Robertson ▪️OL Josh Fryar ▪️WR Reggie Virgil
- Oct 4 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy is ACTIVE for today's game, even though they could have had him inactive as the emergency 3rd QB INTERESTING Giants inactives: S Ar’Darius Washington, RB Devin Singletary, CB Nikko Reed, OLB Jihad Ward, OL J.C. Davis, TE Thomas Fidone II, DL Bobby Jamison-Travis
- Oct 4 Dan Duggan (X) Giants-Cardinals pregame thoughts: • Is this Jameis Winston's last stand? It would be much better for the Giants if Winston can settle down and play well enough so they don't need to rush JJ McCarthy onto the field. But the clock is going to be ticking if it doesn't look better than the past two appearances. The Giants haven't scored a TD in the 7+ quarters since Jaxson Dart's injury and they're 0-for-4 in the red zone the past two games. Don't need to see vintage Jameis slinging it all over the field, but would like to see them open up the offense a bit. This is a bad defense. You invested in Winston for this moment, at least show a little trust in him. • The Winston point ties into Malik Nabers. He has six catches for 27 yards over the past two games. He's still not back to top form, but this is a matchup that could get him there. But need to scheme some plays downfield/in the open field. Enough screens into the teeth of the defense. • The Cardinals have an efficient offense…
- Oct 4 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy arrives for his first game as a Giant
- Oct 4 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy will be the third-string quarterback in his first game with the Giants.
- Oct 4 Mike Garafolo (X) The Insiders for @NFLGameDay Kickoff on Drake Maye’s struggles without #Patriots WR A.J. Brown, #Lions and Sam LaPorta breaking off contract talks, J.J. McCarthy starting his #Giants stint as QB3 for now and Brian Schottenheimer’s message to the #Cowboys.
-
J.J. McCarthy: Out
Est. return: Sep 27
1 more updatefrom 1 source
- Sep 27 ESPN NFL Injury Report J.J. McCarthy: Out
- Sep 27 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) Vikings inactives vs. Buccaneers Brett Thorson Zemaiah Vaughn Jakobe Thomas Tavierre Thomas Caleb Tiernan Elijah Williams J.J. McCarthy (emergency 3rd QB) Ivan Pace flew to Tampa this morning, and is active today.
-
J.J. McCarthy: Out
Est. return: Oct 4
-
[Pelissero] The Vikings are signing QB Max Brosmer from the practice squad to the 53-man roster, per source.
With the J.J. McCarthy trade complete, the move allows Brosmer to be inactive but dress as the emergency No. 3 QB behind Kyler Murray and Carson Wentz.
19 more updatesfrom 13 sources
- Sep 29 Jordan Schultz (X) #Bills star DE Greg Rousseau tells me the new scheme under Jim Leonhard and the impact of DT Deone Walker are among the things that have helped his game take off even more this season — and the numbers prove it. 💪💪💪 · Quoting Jordan Schultz: 🚨 #Bills star DE and NFL sack leader Greg Rousseau joined me this week on The Schultz Report. I also give some intel on the latest NFL news — including the #Giants’ trade for JJ McCarthy and the why behind it. 👀 📺 WATCH NOW
- Sep 29 Pro Football Talk With No. 9 taken in New York, J.J. McCarthy switches to No. 18
- Sep 29 Daily Norseman (MIN) On the McCarthy Trade and Week 3 Observations
- Sep 29 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) With tight end Isaiah Likely wearing No. 9, new Giants QB J.J. McCarthy now will wear No. 18, per the team’s website.+1
- Sep 29 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) We're losing recipes · Quoting NFL Daily News: JJ McCarthy to wear No. 18 with the Giants.
- Sep 29 NFL Daily News (Bluesky) JJ McCarthy to wear No. 18 with the Giants.
- Sep 29 Daily Norseman (MIN) Vikings sign RB Devin Neal amidst flurry of roster moves
- Sep 29 Judy Battista (X) There were a lot of circumstances that led to the J.J. McCarthy failure in Minnesota. Missteps will have to be owned across the #Vikings organization and by McCarthy, too. Subscribe today for the latest from NFL Blue Book...
- Sep 29 Dan Duggan (X) Yes. Isaiah Likely said JJ McCarthy was in the team meeting today · Quoting B2, All aboard the JJ Train. 🏈 2-16: Bruh, Can someone tell me if JJ is in even in the building? I haven't heard ish someone?? And if he isn't why? @DDuggan21 @art_stapleton @JordanRaanan
- Sep 29 Jordan Schultz (X) 🚨 #Bills star DE and NFL sack leader Greg Rousseau joined me this week on The Schultz Report. I also give some intel on the latest NFL news — including the #Giants’ trade for JJ McCarthy and the why behind it. 👀 📺 WATCH NOW
- Sep 29 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Pelissero] The Vikings are signing QB Max Brosmer from the practice squad to the 53-man roster, per source. With the J.J. McCarthy trade complete, the move allows Brosmer to be inactive but dress as the emergency No. 3 QB behind Kyler Murray and Carson Wentz.
- Sep 29 CBS Sports NFL Headlines The Giants' trade for J.J. McCarthy makes no sense -- for more reasons than one
- Sep 29 Daily Norseman (MIN) Vikings 3-0: J.J. McCarthy Traded, Kyler Murray Wasn’t the Problem, Defense Is Record-Breaking
- Sep 29 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Why the Giants' J.J. McCarthy Trade Isn't as Bad as Critics Claim
- Sep 29 Pro Football Talk J.J. McCarthy joins a small group of first-round quarterbacks who made quick exits
- Sep 29 Mike Garafolo (X) From @gmfb on the #Giants trading for QB JJ McCarthy from the #Vikings.
- Sep 29 CBS Sports NFL Headlines Case Keenum, Bears score 'MNF' win over Eagles; MLB Wild Card preview; WNBA awards top rookie
- Sep 29 CBS Sports NFL Headlines When will J.J. McCarthy start for Giants? Why John Harbaugh could make QB change sooner than expected
- Sep 29 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) Mike Wobschall of Bleav in Vikings joins Ed Valentine of Big Blue View to help us understand what the #NYGiants are getting in quarterback J.J. McCarthy.
-
John Harbaugh says on Zoom that J.J. McCarthy being the No. 2 backup QB in Washington is a "possibility" and something that's "on the table."
McCarthy was one of three active QBs on Sunday against the Cardinals. He did not play, but he was engaged, looking at the play sheet on his wrist constantly, with his helmet on, throughout as Jameis Winston led the offense and Jake Haener was available, too
2 more updatesfrom 2 sources
- Oct 5 Dan Duggan (X) Harbaugh said it’s a “possibility” that JJ McCarthy will be QB2 this week. They didn’t bring him in to sit behind Jake Haener on the depth chart, so I’d expect that to happen. Harbaugh said “we’ll see” on the center decision for this week. Harbaugh praised Bryan Hudson’s performance yesterday, but said John Michael Schmitz was playing “really well,” too. Called it a good problem to have.
- Oct 5 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy could get up to speed and be the backup next Sunday vs. Washington. "Think that's a possibility," John Harbaugh said. Believes it's realistic and "on the table."
- Oct 5 Pat Leonard (X) John Harbaugh says on Zoom that J.J. McCarthy being the No. 2 backup QB in Washington is a "possibility" and something that's "on the table." McCarthy was one of three active QBs on Sunday against the Cardinals. He did not play, but he was engaged, looking at the play sheet on his wrist constantly, with his helmet on, throughout as Jameis Winston led the offense and Jake Haener was available, too
- J.J. McCarthy QB2 on this week’s Giants depth chart behind Jameis Winston by virtue of Jake Haener technically being on the practice squad. But John Harbaugh did say it’s “on the table” that McCarthy is Sunday’s true backup in Washington
-
J.J. McCarthy: Out
Sep 13: McCarthy (coach's decision) is inactive but will serve as the Vikings' emergency third quarterback against the Packers on Sunday, Craig Peters of the Vikings' official site reports.
7 more updatesfrom 5 sources
- Sep 13 ESPN NFL Injury Report J.J. McCarthy: Out
- Sep 13 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) Kyler Murray is out for the game, the Vikings announced. It'll be Carson Wentz, with J.J. McCarthy one snap away as the emergency third QB.
- Sep 13 Alec Lewis (X) Vikings QB Carson Wentz didn't get many reps early in camp due to the competition between Kyler Murray and J.J. McCarthy. Started to get more last couple of weeks, but not fully in sync here.
- Sep 13 Andrew Krammer (Bluesky) Vikings inactives vs. Green Bay S Jakobe Thomas RB Demond Claiborne CB Zemaiah Vaughn C Nick Samac OT Caleb Tiernan DT Elijah Williams QB J.J. McCarthy (No. 3 QB) Packers without LG Aaron Banks (knee), but RT Zach Bako-Bewele is active+2
- Sep 13 ESPN NFL Injury Report J.J. McCarthy: Out
- Sep 13 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) #Vikings inactives vs. Packers J.J. McCarthy (emergency third QB) Zemaiah Vaughn Jakobe Thomas Demond Claiborne Nick Samac Caleb Tiernan Aaron Banks is down for the Packers
-
Jim Harbaugh did speak to his brother John Harbaugh before the Giants traded for QB J.J. McCarthy. 📹 @alexinsdorf99
21 more updatesfrom 16 sources
- Sep 30 CBS Sports NFL Headlines Russell Wilson explains why Giants' controversial J.J. McCarthy trade could be a 'great' fit
- Sep 30 Jacob Westendorf (X) Harbaugh crime family @by_JBH · Quoting Adam Schefter: Jim Harbaugh did speak to his brother John Harbaugh before the Giants traded for QB J.J. McCarthy. 📹 @alexinsdorf99
- Sep 30 Pro Football Talk Jim Harbaugh, to no surprise, spoke to John Harbaugh before J.J. McCarthy trade
- Sep 30 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) Jim Harbaugh did speak to his brother John Harbaugh before the Giants traded for QB J.J. McCarthy. 📹 @alexinsdorf99+1
- Sep 30 Jordan Raanan (X) Jameis Winston was doing some static stretching and bear crawls after throwing to receivers following practice. New quarterback J.J. McCarthy joined. Winston said he welcomes McCarthy. Early impression is that he's a "good kid" and "curious."
- Sep 30 Pat Leonard (X) No J.J. McCarthy interview today after his first practice with the Giants. He is scheduled to speak later in the week
- Sep 30 Daily Norseman (MIN) Minnesota Vikings News and Links: Onward And Upward!
- Sep 30 Kris Rhim (X) Jim Harbaugh on JJ McCarthy going to New York: "John [Harbaugh] called me and asked me. I said, 'John, I love you. I love JJ.'"
- Sep 30 Dan Duggan (X) When is the earliest the Giants could turn to J.J. McCarthy at quarterback? @Connor_J_Hughes and @DDuggan21 on NYG411
- Sep 30 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Who Is J.J. McCarthy? A Closer Look at the Giants' New Backup Quarterback
- Sep 30 Dan Duggan (X) And here’s your first look at JJ McCarthy · Quoting Charlotte Carroll: J.J. McCarthy out at #giants practice today in the No. 18
- Sep 30 Dan Duggan (X) J.J. McCarthy out at #giants practice today in the No. 18
- Sep 30 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) Kevin O’Connell said the #Vikings “tried to do everything we could” to develop J.J. McCarthy. So why didn’t it work? A look at the factors that threw McCarthy’s time in Minnesota off course
- Sep 30 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Scouting J.J. McCarthy: The Good, the Great, and the Ugly of the Giants' New QB2 (via Coach Gene Clemons)
- Sep 30 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) More disturbing than J.J. McCarthy not being Nine in New York is the revelation that a tight end is WEARING NUMBER NINE
- Sep 30 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants-Cardinals Week 4 Storylines: J.J. McCarthy Arrives, Pass Rush Under Pressure+1
- Sep 30 Albert Breer (X) On JJ McCarthy and what his crash ending with the @Vikings tells us about quarterbacking in the NFL—and his road out with the @Giants.
- Sep 30 Judy Battista (X) Lots of insight here from Charles about J.J. McCarthy's arc in Minnesota. · Quoting Charles Robinson: There were a lot of circumstances that led to the J.J. McCarthy failure in Minnesota. Missteps will have to be owned across the #Vikings organization and by McCarthy, too. Subscribe today for the latest from NFL Blue Book...
- Sep 30 Alec Lewis (X) How did the Vikings’ major investment in J.J. McCarthy go so south so quickly? “I knew this was going to be up and down when we made that choice this spring (to move forward with McCarthy as the starter), but it has just been brutal.” Capturing what became a chaotic journey, from start to finish
- Sep 30 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) For your morning commute!! 🚙 Check out the latest episode of the Between The Hashmarks Podcast, as @miketanier.bsky.social and I put four “contenders” into the worry meter, debate JJ McCarthy’s impact, and more!
-
J.J. McCarthy said it was a bit of a "shock" that he was traded. But at the end of the day, "it's an opportunity" to show what he can do with the Giants.
He's looking into the present. Putting the Vikings in the past.
13 more updatesfrom 8 sources
- Oct 2 Pat Leonard (X) J.J. McCarthy sees “opportunity” with Giants after “shock” of Vikings trade+1
- Oct 2 Albert Breer (X) 🎙️🎙️ 10.1 Pod 🎙️🎙️ @ConorOrr and I break down the week's two big trades—with the @Steelers landing Joey Porter Jr. and the @Giants getting JJ McCarthy—then dive into all the Week 4 action ahead. It's all here ... Download AND subscribe
- Oct 2 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy's Crash Course: Inside the Giants' Plan to Get Their New QB Up to Speed
- Oct 2 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants OC Matt Nagy Reveals What's Impressed Him Most So Far About J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 2 ESPN NFL News McCarthy: Trade to Giants a 'shock,' turns page on Vikings
- Oct 2 Daily Norseman (MIN) Norse Code Podcast Episode 616: General Kirk-iness (with guest Kevin Fielder)
- Oct 2 Pat Leonard (X) 🎙️LISTEN: J.J. McCarthy’s first full interview as a New York Giants QB He talked about his new Giants fit, how organizations can support young QBs, the shock of the trade, outreach to Jaxson Dart and more
- Oct 2 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy said it was a bit of a "shock" that he was traded. But at the end of the day, "it's an opportunity" to show what he can do with the Giants. He's looking into the present. Putting the Vikings in the past.
- Oct 2 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy spent most of his time this week learning the offense. Coach John Harbaugh said the Giants are still trying to figure whether he will be the second or third-string quarterback. Jameis Winston is the starter and took the first-team reps.
- Oct 2 Pat Leonard (X) Jameis Winston said this week that he is taking the “majority” of the #Giants QB reps at practice. Just asked John Harbaugh if he is giving reps to other QBs. He sidestepped the question, basically Seems like Giants are giving backup Jake Haener some reps, too, with J.J. McCarthy running scout team. Harbaugh says gameday QB plan isn’t yet set This is different than early season, when Jaxson Dart took all the reps and the. Winston entered and struggled in L.A.
- Oct 2 Pat Leonard (X) “There’s a little bit of the sinker ball with a couple of the low throws that he had over the middle of the field. Jameis will tell you that. Mechanically, Jameis knows to keep that wide base to be able to throw through the throw and make a friendlier catch for some of these passes.” “We need to score touchdowns. Our players, our coaches, everyone here believes in Jameis. Everybody.” The J.J. McCarthy trade puts pressure on Jameis Winston to perform. Immediately. Or else
- Oct 2 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy spent the week as the scout team quarterback. He's learning the Giants offense, which John Harbaugh said will be a "challenge." It will take some time for McCarthy to get up to speed. We'll likely hear from him later today to see how he's progressing.
- Oct 2 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) Jameis Winston is the #NYGiants quarterback. That is important to remember with all the focus on J.J. McCarthy.
-
Kevin O’Connell said the Vikings will start Carson Wentz on Sunday. Kyler Murray made progress this week, and should be out of the concussion protocol by next week. J.J. McCarthy will be the backup.
Jauan Jennings will be out after the loss of a close family member. Brian O’Neill is questionable.
2 more updatesfrom 2 sources
- Sep 18 Ben Goessling (Bluesky) Kevin O’Connell said the Vikings will start Carson Wentz on Sunday. Kyler Murray made progress this week, and should be out of the concussion protocol by next week. J.J. McCarthy will be the backup. Jauan Jennings will be out after the loss of a close family member. Brian O’Neill is questionable.
- Sep 18 NFL Daily News (Bluesky) Vikings QB Carson Wentz will start in Week 2. J.J. McCarthy will serve as QB2.
- Sep 18 NFL News Poster (Bluesky) [Vikings] Head Coach Kevin O'Connell announces that Carson Wentz will start Sunday at Chicago and J.J. McCarthy will serve as the team's backup.
-
I can’t rule anything out, but I think it would be crazy to trade anything for a QB. They committed to Jameis as the backup. This is why. Weird that the first reaction by so many now that the backup has to play is it’s time to find an upgrade.
I get it if people are spooked by the performance Monday, but if Jameis was consistent, he wouldn’t be a backup. He’s just as likely to throw for 400 yards Sunday as he is to look like he did in LA.
Don’t see the point in trading for a young QB, who would need to learn the offense on the fly. Now, if you want to sign a vet like Jimmy G to back-up Jameis and provide a Plan B if Monday wasn’t an aberration, I can understand that · Quoting ReterRarker: @DDuggan21 Any chance they go out and trade for JJ McCarthy? We need a mobile QB to run this offense. Not built for a Jameis Winston
1 more updatefrom 1 source
- Sep 23 Dan Duggan (X) I can’t rule anything out, but I think it would be crazy to trade anything for a QB. They committed to Jameis as the backup. This is why. Weird that the first reaction by so many now that the backup has to play is it’s time to find an upgrade. I get it if people are spooked by the performance Monday, but if Jameis was consistent, he wouldn’t be a backup. He’s just as likely to throw for 400 yards Sunday as he is to look like he did in LA. Don’t see the point in trading for a young QB, who would need to learn the offense on the fly. Now, if you want to sign a vet like Jimmy G to back-up Jameis and provide a Plan B if Monday wasn’t an aberration, I can understand that · Quoting ReterRarker: @DDuggan21 Any chance they go out and trade for JJ McCarthy? We need a mobile QB to run this offense. Not built for a Jameis Winston
- Sep 23 Dan Duggan (X) @DDuggan21 Any chance they go out and trade for JJ McCarthy? We need a mobile QB to run this offense. Not built for a Jameis Winston
-
Vikings HC Kevin O'Connell says QB Carson Wentz will be the backup. J.J. McCarthy will be the No. 3. Kevin said he's looking at that right now as a "week-to-week thing."
13 more updatesfrom 9 sources
- Sep 9 ESPN NFL News McCarthy to open season as Vikings' No. 3 QB
- Sep 9 CBS Sports NFL Headlines Vikings name ex-top 10 pick J.J. McCarthy third quarterback for Week 1 vs. Packers; Carson Wentz backup
- Sep 9 Will Ragatz (X) Kevin O’Connell says naming Carson Wentz as QB2 "gives us the best chance to win this Sunday." On J.J. McCarthy: "He’s been incredibly professional, the conversations that him and I have had. He’s excited to continue to grow and get better. He’s still a young quarterback in the NFL, with 10 starts and a bunch of talent and a bunch of things that make him a guy that we want to pour into every single day. And the best part is, he’s gonna work as hard as anybody.”+1
- Sep 9 Mike Chappell (X) JJ McCarthy. · Quoting Adam Schefter: Vikings HC Kevin O'Connell announced Carson Wentz will be the No. 2 backup QB on Sunday vs. the Packers and J.J. McCarthy will be QB3.+1
- Sep 9 Mike Garafolo (X) O’Connell tells reporters this is the combination that gives the #Vikings the best chance to win this Sunday against the #Packers. · Quoting Minnesota Vikings: Head Coach Kevin O'Connell has announced that Carson Wentz will serve as the team's backup QB on Sunday and that J.J. McCarthy will serve as the 3rd QB. O'Connell says it'll be a week-to-week thing as far as the backup QB spot goes.
- Sep 9 Josh Weinfuss (X) Look at @JJWatt breaking news… · Quoting Kevin Seifert: Kevin O'Connell confirms that Carson Wentz will be QB2 and J.J. McCarthy will be QB3 behind QB1 Kyler Murray. O'Connell: This gives us the best chance to win this Sunday."
- Sep 9 Mike Chappell (X) Vikings HC Kevin O'Connell announced Carson Wentz will be the No. 2 backup QB on Sunday vs. the Packers and J.J. McCarthy will be QB3.
- Sep 9 Josh Weinfuss (X) Kevin O'Connell confirms that Carson Wentz will be QB2 and J.J. McCarthy will be QB3 behind QB1 Kyler Murray. O'Connell: This gives us the best chance to win this Sunday."+1
- Sep 9 Andrew Krammer (Bluesky) Carson Wentz will be the Vikings' QB2 vs Green Bay, Kevin O'Connell said. J.J. McCarthy will be the emergency QB3. "It's a week to week thing," O'Connell said.
- Sep 9 Mike Garafolo (X) Head Coach Kevin O'Connell has announced that Carson Wentz will serve as the team's backup QB on Sunday and that J.J. McCarthy will serve as the 3rd QB. O'Connell says it'll be a week-to-week thing as far as the backup QB spot goes.
- Sep 9 Will Ragatz (X) Carson Wentz will be the Vikings' backup QB on Sunday, Kevin O'Connell says. J.J. McCarthy will be QB3. KOC says he's looking at it as a "week to week" thing.
-
Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy won’t play tonight against Broncos, multiple sources told The Athletic. The team had hoped McCarthy’s ankle would heal ahead of the game. McCarthy ultimately was not comfortable enough to go. The injury is considered minor, and he’s day to day.
1 more updatefrom 1 source
- Aug 28 Will Ragatz (X) No J.J. McCarthy tonight · Quoting Alec Lewis: Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy won’t play tonight against Broncos, multiple sources told The Athletic. The team had hoped McCarthy’s ankle would heal ahead of the game. McCarthy ultimately was not comfortable enough to go. The injury is considered minor, and he’s day to day.
- Aug 28 Alec Lewis (X) Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy won’t play tonight against Broncos, multiple sources told The Athletic. The team had hoped McCarthy’s ankle would heal ahead of the game. McCarthy ultimately was not comfortable enough to go. The injury is considered minor, and he’s day to day.
- JJ McCarthy Justin Fields Anthony Richardson Kirk Cousins Davis Mills Mitch Trubisky · Quoting Steven Ruiz: If Darnold is out for the season, do you look for an upgrade over Lock? Feels like a tough spot, where Lock probably isn't good enough to sustain a successful offense but just good enough that they don't feel pressure to replace him
-
J.J. McCarthy: Questionable
Aug 30: McCarthy (ankle) remains on the 53-man roster for the Vikings, Adam Schefter of ESPN reports.
5 more updatesfrom 4 sources
- Aug 30 ESPN NFL Injury Report J.J. McCarthy: Questionable
- Aug 30 Mike Garafolo (X) Feels like teams either have too many or too few QBs this year. The #Vikings keep 4. · Quoting James Palmer: The Vikings officially on their official 53 have 4 QBs: Kyler Murray, J.J. McCarthy, Carson Wentz, Max Brosmer
- Aug 30 Mike Garafolo (X) The Vikings officially on their official 53 have 4 QBs: Kyler Murray, J.J. McCarthy, Carson Wentz, Max Brosmer+1
- Aug 30 Will Ragatz (X) J.J. McCarthy will be on the Vikings' initial 53-man roster. · Quoting Adam Schefter: Despite any speculation that he could be released or traded, Minnesota QB J.J. McCarthy finished cutdown day on the Vikings’ 53-man roster.
- Aug 30 Adam Schefter (X) Despite any speculation that he could be released or traded, Minnesota QB J.J. McCarthy finished cutdown day on the Vikings’ 53-man roster.
The River 34 newest first
- Vic Fangio: J.J. McCarthy was a "steal" for the Giants
- Top 3 Streamers for Week 9 in Fantasy Football! Waiver Wire Pickups #shorts
- Make sure you hit the right target on the Week 9 Waiver Wire 👀 🎯 Tyler Allgeier 🎯 Antonio Williams 🎯 J.J. McCarthy 📽️ @colinmctamany.bsky.social
- Another rough day for the NFC East with its best player J.J. McCarthy on bye
-
Thought this was telling. Asked J.J. McCarthy if he felt more comfortable than previous years.
McCarthy: "For sure. Just overall, regardless of team, I feel such a different peace going out there on the field every single time I step out there just being in Year 2 now of playing."
4 more updatesfrom 1 source
- 6d Dan Duggan (X) 💻 @kurt13warner Has #BigBlue found their QB in JJ McCarthy? What's the film study show after the Week 7 win in Houston? #NFL
- 6d Dan Duggan (X) Tried to cheat the game here by making the conversation about how we shouldn’t be having the conversation · Quoting SNY Giants: Is it too early to talk Giants QB situation between Jaxson Dart and J.J. McCarthy? @Connor_J_Hughes and @DDuggan21 on NYG411
- 6d Dan Duggan (X) Is it too early to talk Giants QB situation between Jaxson Dart and J.J. McCarthy? @Connor_J_Hughes and @DDuggan21 on NYG411
- 6d Dan Duggan (X) Giants offensive snap counts vs. the Texans: • The Giants subbed Jameis Winston in for five tush-push plays. He converted sneaks on a third-and-1 and a fourth-and-1. It took him two tries to sneak it in from the 1 for a TD. All of the sneaks opened up the 19-yard handoff to Cam Skattebo from the tush-push alignment. • The backfield was shaping up as an even split before Tyrone Tracy left with a hamstring injury in the second quarter. Skattebo had played 14 snaps compared to 11 snaps for Tracy at that point. Both backs and Devin Singletary played on early third downs. As the game progressed, Singletary took over as the third-down back while mixing in on early downs. Skattebo indicated his hamstring was OK after the game and he has the bye to recover, but after Tracy's surprise addition to IR yesterday, let's wait and see where he's at when they return to practice next week. Skattebo missed chunks of time last offseason with a hamstring. It's tempting to look at the results when…
- 6d Jordan Raanan (X) Thought this was telling. Asked J.J. McCarthy if he felt more comfortable than previous years. McCarthy: "For sure. Just overall, regardless of team, I feel such a different peace going out there on the field every single time I step out there just being in Year 2 now of playing."
- Feeling stuck? Find some answers on the Week 8 Waiver Wire 💥 Omar Cooper Jr. 💥 Jonah Coleman 💥 J.J. McCarthy 📽️ @colinmctamany.bsky.social #Jets #Broncos #Giants #NFL #FantasyFootball
-
Just how good was J.J. McCarthy:
CPOE: +9.2% (2nd)
Tight-window completions: 4 (T-1st)
Tight-window attempts: 4
Air Yards per att: 9.9 (2nd)
Pressure Rate faced: 46.7% (6th)
6 more updatesfrom 5 sources
- Oct 26 Josina Anderson (X) Are the same people critizing Harbs last week, complimenting the #Giants head coach this week? 😂 JJ McCarthy also did a masterful job channeling rejection from his former team & getting locked in for his 1st win as QB1 for the #Giants now.. · Quoting JosinaAnderson: NEW: How #Giants head coach John Harbaugh's win in Houston reminded me of Phil Jackson, after Cam Skattebo's career-best rushing performance vs the #Texans, a week after Harbs was criticized for benching his star running back.
- Oct 26 Jeremy Fowler (X) In the offseason, the Vikings challenged J.J. McCarthy to improve his throwing versatility -- more clubs in the bag. Not just the fastball, but more layering of the ball. He lost the QB battle, but Minnesota noticed he improved in that area. Showed Sunday -- with a different team. · Quoting Mina Kimes: ….man what
- Oct 26 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) The Sunday Aftermath. Breaking down J.J. McCarthy's revival, Omar Cooper Jr.'s ongoing breakout, the Texans' receiver mess and much more in my Week 7 recap
- Oct 26 Pat Leonard (X) Relive McCarthy’s every throw here · Quoting ΛWTHΞИƬIK: Every JJ McCarthy throw and run vs the Texans 🔥 – 20/28 – 252 yards – Sacked 3x – 99.1 Rating #NYGIANTS
- Oct 26 Pat Leonard (X) Have to ask J.J. about this lol · Quoting Jack Mac: JACK MAC DEBRIEF NFL WEEK 7 🏈JJ McCarthy ditched the eyeblack to beat CJ Stroud once again 🏈Skattebo calls out the NFL 🏈Joe Burrow…a tale of 2 halves 🏈The Jets return to factory settings 🏈Butker has a STINKER…K9 runs off 🏈Legendary ref 🏈By the order of the French Peaky Bliders MUCH MORE
- Oct 26 Jordan Raanan (X) This was perhaps J.J. McCarthy's best throw. It's third-and-9 in the fourth quarter of a tight game. Gets it into a tight window to Malachi Fields. · Quoting Jordan Raanan: Just how good was J.J. McCarthy: CPOE: +9.2% (2nd) Tight-window completions: 4 (T-1st) Tight-window attempts: 4 Air Yards per att: 9.9 (2nd) Pressure Rate faced: 46.7% (6th)
- Oct 26 Jordan Raanan (X) Just how good was J.J. McCarthy: CPOE: +9.2% (2nd) Tight-window completions: 4 (T-1st) Tight-window attempts: 4 Air Yards per att: 9.9 (2nd) Pressure Rate faced: 46.7% (6th)
- Giants' John Harbaugh details J.J. McCarthy decision with convincing explanation: 'Heck of a skill set'
- Our Week 7 preview pod is up. We talked matchups for every game, including a potentially fun Lions-Packers game, Saints-Steelers in Paris for some reason, how the Rams might operate with Davante Adams done, and JJ McCarthy szn (Giants vs. Texans).
- Settle in with your morning coffee, and what I’m hearing from sources across the league on the NFL’s biggest storylines! ☕️ · Quoting Matt Lombardo: NFL Mailbag is Here!! 📬 One coordinator’s expectations for J.J. McCarthy’s first start, NFL Coach Hot Seat Rankings, and a couple of trade targets for the Bills, as the deadline approaches!
-
Big opportunity for J.J. McCarthy's career. Not this game but rest of this season.
Wide range of outcomes. Could be great and live up to potential. Also could go poorly. There is no guarantee he is better than Jameis.
A lot at stake for Giants and McCarthy. · Quoting Neil: @JordanRaanan I look forward to J.J. showing what he can do with this opportunity.
11 more updatesfrom 7 sources
- Oct 23 RotoBaller NFL Who Should I Start for Fantasy Football Week 7? Aaron Rodgers, Kyler Murray, C.J. Stroud, Geno Smith, Kirk Cousins, Bryce Young, J.J. McCarthy, Michael Penix Jr., Baker Mayfield, Tyler Shough
- Oct 23 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) One coach I spoke briefly with today called J.J. McCarthy getting his first start “one of the biggest storylines of the weekend.” @miketanier.bsky.social and I each have wildly different views on this whole thing …
- Oct 23 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) NFL Mailbag is Here!! 📬 One coordinator’s expectations for J.J. McCarthy’s first start, NFL Coach Hot Seat Rankings, and a couple of trade targets for the Bills, as the deadline approaches!
- Oct 23 Jordan Raanan (X) If J.J. McCarthy plays lights out, it's always a possibility. That is how this league works. It's highly unlikely but Tom Brady once took the job from a perennial Pro Bowler who was the league's highest-paid QB. · Quoting Kushal Doshi: @JordanRaanan I wonder what happens if JJ leads us to the playoffs. Do we have a QB controversy in 2027?
- Oct 23 Daily Norseman (MIN) Week 7 Preview (And a J.J. McCarthy Take)
- Oct 23 Matt Lombardo (Bluesky) I’d suggest Giants fans temper expectations for J.J. McCarthy on Sunday … As @ftnfantasy.com points out, McCarthy posted a pedestrian 33.8 passer rating when pressured last season, while posting a minus-105.3 DVOA on pressured snaps, sixth-worst among QBs … Against the Texans on Sunday … 😵💫
- Oct 23 Aaron Wilson (X) #Texans Pro Bowl corner Kamari Lassiter on matchup with #Giants Malik Nabers, J.J. McCarthy, ups and downs of season
- Oct 23 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants Reopen More of the Playbook for J.J. McCarthy’s First Start vs. Texans
- Oct 23 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Was J.J. McCarthy’s spark real or Fool’s gold? Listen to the latest episode of Locked On Giants. 📸 Vincent Carchietta-IMAGN Images
- Oct 23 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Why Isaiah Likely Is Sold on New Starting Giants QB J.J. McCarthy
- Oct 23 Texans Team Site Know Your Foe: How the Texans Can Beat John Harbaugh's NFC East-Leading Giants
- Oct 23 Jordan Raanan (X) Big opportunity for J.J. McCarthy's career. Not this game but rest of this season. Wide range of outcomes. Could be great and live up to potential. Also could go poorly. There is no guarantee he is better than Jameis. A lot at stake for Giants and McCarthy. · Quoting Neil: @JordanRaanan I look forward to J.J. showing what he can do with this opportunity.
-
NFL Week 7 upset alert: Can Giants upset Texans with JJ McCarthy at QB? Can Falcons beat 49ers?
13 more updatesfrom 8 sources
- Oct 22 Aaron Wilson (X) #Texans DC Matt Burke on J.J. McCarthy, they have gone back and watched #Vikings games too: 'Really athletic. Trying to go back and make sure crossing all out Ts and dotting all our Is'
- Oct 22 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Jameis Winston Takes Demotion in Stride as J.J. McCarthy Steps In for Giants
- Oct 22 Dan Duggan (X) It was always a matter of when — not if — the Giants would start JJ McCarthy. So, why now?
- Oct 22 Dan Duggan (X) This is insane. Giants’ starting QBs from Week 11 of the 2004 season through Week 2 of the 2019 season: Eli Manningx232 · Quoting Bobby Skinner: Giants QB’s since Eli Manning was benched in 2019. New name added to the list! Daniel Jones x10 Eli Manning x2 Daniel Jones x13 Colt McCoy x1 Daniel Jones x1 Colt McCoy x1 Daniel Jones x13 Mike Glennon x3 Jake Fromm x1 Mike Glennon x1 Jake Fromm x1 Daniel Jones x16 Davis Webb x1 Daniel Jones x5 Tyrod Taylor x3 Daniel Jones x1 Tommy Devito x6 Tyrod Taylor x2 Daniel Jones x10 Tommy Devito x1 Drew Lock x2 Tommy Devito x1 Drew Lock x3 Russell Wilson x3 Jaxson Dart x7 Jameis Winston x2 Jaxson Dart x7 Jameis Winston x4 JJ McCarthy x?
- Oct 22 Jordan Raanan (X) Matt Nagy said that J.J. McCarthy's "skill set is very similar to Jaxson (Dart)." It brings back a decent percentage of the playbook. #Giants
- Oct 22 Pat Leonard (X) Giants OC Matt Nagy said he had a highlights on his call sheet in Washington that narrowed the play call options to 50% of the offense if J.J. McCarthy had to go in full time. Then it was 90% last week against the Saints. Now it goes to 100% with him taking the starting role
- Oct 22 Dan Duggan (X) Giants QB’s since Eli Manning was benched in 2019. New name added to the list! Daniel Jones x10 Eli Manning x2 Daniel Jones x13 Colt McCoy x1 Daniel Jones x1 Colt McCoy x1 Daniel Jones x13 Mike Glennon x3 Jake Fromm x1 Mike Glennon x1 Jake Fromm x1 Daniel Jones x16 Davis Webb x1 Daniel Jones x5 Tyrod Taylor x3 Daniel Jones x1 Tommy Devito x6 Tyrod Taylor x2 Daniel Jones x10 Tommy Devito x1 Drew Lock x2 Tommy Devito x1 Drew Lock x3 Russell Wilson x3 Jaxson Dart x7 Jameis Winston x2 Jaxson Dart x7 Jameis Winston x4 JJ McCarthy x?
- Oct 22 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Why J.J. McCarthy Feels Better Prepared for Giants' Starting Opportunity
- Oct 22 Jeremy Fowler (X) Seems like a good week to bring this back. The Harbaugh family faith in McCarthy remains high. · Quoting Jeremy Fowler: Jim Harbaugh doubled down on J.J. McCarthy: “I think he’s the best quarterback in the draft,” he said from AFC coaches breakfast. Says a ‘killer comes out’ when adversity hits.
- Oct 22 FantasyPros (YouTube) Fantasy Football Week 7 Rankings & Tiers | WR Studs, Busts & Sleepers (2026)
- Oct 22 CBS Sports NFL Headlines Prisco's NFL Week 7 picks ahead of Patriots vs. Bears; Dream take WNBA Finals lead on Valkyries
- Oct 22 CBS Sports NFL Headlines It wouldn't shock me IF ... NFL Week 7: Broncos bench Bo Nix, Kenneth Walker III has muted return to Seattle
- Oct 22 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy is the Giants starting quarterback for the foreseeable future.
- Oct 22 CBS Sports NFL Headlines NFL Week 7 upset alert: Can Giants upset Texans with JJ McCarthy at QB? Can Falcons beat 49ers?
- We also touched on the coming JJ McCarthy Experience, which will be stupid and fun but mostly stupid.
-
Giants have a QB controversy: J.J. McCarthy makes case to replace Jameis Winston
11 more updatesfrom 7 sources
- Oct 19 Denny Carter (Bluesky) The @rotopat.bsky.social take on JJ McCarthy's Week 6 performance is as good as anticipated. Sunday Aftermath
- Oct 19 Pat Leonard (X) Jameis Winston should continue to start at quarterback for John Harbaugh. A veteran hand gives the Giants their best chance to win the franchise's first NFC East title since 2011 in a weak division. But the Giants' coach sounded Monday like he may be leaning toward making the switch to J.J. McCarthy for Sunday's road game against the Houston Texans. Harbaugh referred to the Giants' ongoing search to "find themselves" when it comes to balancing the offense, running the football and reclaiming an identity they lost when Jaxson Dart went down in Week 2. The coach did not pick Winston or McCarthy on Monday. But it seems clear Harbaugh is leaning toward tabbing McCarthy as his starter soon, whether it's Sunday in Houston or on Nov. 8 in Philadelphia after the Giants' Week 8 bye
- Oct 19 CBS Sports NFL Headlines John Harbaugh provides update on Giants' QB situation between JJ McCarthy, Jameis Winston
- Oct 19 Pro Football Talk John Harbaugh: We're "honing in" on who will start at QB in Week 7
- Oct 19 Pat Leonard (X) John Harbaugh hasn't picked a starting QB yet. But he did acknowledge that whatever decision he makes, he will explain to the team what he's doing and why, since it's the QB position. Harbaugh also spoke in today's press conference about the team trying to find itself and losing its original identity when Jaxson Dart went down. He also called them a "work in progress." Frankly, Harbaugh sounds like someone who is about to go to J.J. McCarthy. But again, he hasn't said that -- not yet, at least. I'll have a story coming shortly on @NYDNSports
- Oct 19 Adam Schefter (X) Giants’ QB update: · Quoting Jordan Raanan: John Harbaugh says they're "working through that now" on a quarterback decision between Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy. Not ready to name a starter for this week vs. Texans.
- Oct 19 Jordan Raanan (X) John Harbaugh says they're "working through that now" on a quarterback decision between Jameis Winston and J.J. McCarthy. Not ready to name a starter for this week vs. Texans.
- Oct 19 Jordan Raanan (X) J.J. McCarthy threw for a ridiculous 243 yards in the fourth quarter alone on Sunday. When I brought up that stat after the game he immediate said: "Didn't get the win though."
- Oct 19 Patrick Daugherty (Bluesky) The Sunday Aftermath. Breaking down Jalen Hurts' future, J.J. McCarthy's wild cameo, Chris Ballard's firing and much more in my Week 6 recap
- Oct 19 Pat Leonard (X) Something just came across my desk from @BetOnline_ag, John. New prop bet on the board: Will J.J. McCarthy start in Week 7 for the Giants? YES -250 NO +170 #Giants
- Oct 19 Jordan Raanan (X) Jameis Winston or J.J. McCarthy? Cam Skattebo, Najee Harris, Tyrone Tracy Jr or Devin Singletary? The Giants have some decisions to make.
- Oct 19 CBS Sports NFL Headlines Giants have a QB controversy: J.J. McCarthy makes case to replace Jameis Winston
- Interview with the Enemy: New York Giants
-
The J.J. McCarthy package isn't going anywhere...
5 more updatesfrom 4 sources
- Oct 15 John Shipley (X) I learned about this today and they are some sick puppies · Quoting Rotoworld Football: Harbaugh hints at more J.J. McCarthy package plays
- Oct 15 John Shipley (X) Harbaugh hints at more J.J. McCarthy package plays+1
- Oct 15 Jordan Raanan (X) John Harbaugh also hinted the Giants have more in store for the J.J. McCarthy package. We haven't seen it all yet. · Quoting Jordan Raanan: The J.J. McCarthy package isn't going anywhere...
- Oct 15 Pro Football Talk John Harbaugh: We'd be negligent if we didn't see if J.J. McCarthy can help us
- Oct 15 Jordan Raanan (X) The J.J. McCarthy package isn't going anywhere...
- Are the Giants buyers at the deadline? NFL insider Jordan Schultz joins the show to discuss that plus: JJ McCarthy’s real role, why Kayvon Thibodeaux could draw interest, NFL officiating, the NFC East and more. (Photo: Julian Leshay Guadalupe-IMAGN Images)
- John Harbaugh played backup quarterback J.J. McCarthy for five offensive snaps on Sunday seeking an extra spark with read option handoffs, designed QB runs & quick hit passes. The Giants emerged from that experiment with Jameis Winston’s starting job firmly intact & McCarthy’s inclusion looking like a work in progress that might be able to help New York’s anemic running game. Winston’s thoughts on it: “I think coaches get paid a lot of money to make decisions and do what they do. I had a chance to play with one of the best ones of all time in Taysom Hill. So whatever is required for us to win, I am for that.”
- J.J. McCarthy is making an “A-plus” transition and rapidly learning the Giants’ offense. Jameis Winston is still the starter, but the coaches are clearly eager to see what McCarthy can do soon in a game
- Matt Nagy gives J.J. McCarthy an A+ so far. "He's doing really well. That's as best as I can put it. You look back seven days ago when we were up here having the same conversation, he's much further along, which is, again, a credit to our position coaches. ... Proud of him, but this is just the beginning. But I'd say A+ right now."
- Matt Nagy on J.J. McCarthy’s progress in the last week: “It’s an A+.” #giants
-
The Giants elevated Jake Haener, who is likely to be the backup QB on Sunday vs. Arizona. Not enough time for J.J. McCarthy to have full command of a good chunk of the playbook.
Also OLB Trace Ford will make his debut this season with Brian Burns out for the season.
11 more updatesfrom 8 sources
- Oct 3 Daily Norseman (MIN) Bludgeon Them Into Failure — Flores’ D and the Vikings’ 3-0 Start
- Oct 3 Dan Duggan (X) My prediction: QB JJ McCarthy (emergency QB) RB Devin Singletary TE Thomas Fidone OL JC Davis DL Bobby Jamison-Travis CB Nikko Reed S Ar’Darius Washington · Quoting Sam Sternadori: Predict the 7 healthy scratches @DDuggan21
- Oct 3 Jordan Raanan (X) The Giants elevated Jake Haener, who is likely to be the backup QB on Sunday vs. Arizona. Not enough time for J.J. McCarthy to have full command of a good chunk of the playbook. Also OLB Trace Ford will make his debut this season with Brian Burns out for the season.
- Oct 3 Dan Duggan (X) These are the two elevations. This lines up for Haener to be QB2 and JJ MCcarthy to be the emergency third QB · Quoting Dan Duggan: Giants have two seemingly straightforward practice squad elevation candidates for tomorrow: QB Jake Haener and OLB Trace Ford. But they’ve thrown a few roster curveballs already, so we’ll see later…
- Oct 3 Mike Garafolo (X) The #Giants have elevated QB Jake Haener from the practice squad for tomorrow’s game against the #AZCardinals, an indication he’s still the backup to Jameis Winston as J.J. McCarthy gets acclimated to his new team.
- Oct 3 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy Taking Giants' Crash Course in Offense One Day at a Time
- Oct 3 Ed Valentine (Bluesky) Lots of JJ McCarthy questions in our latest #NYGiants mailbag.
- Oct 3 Jordan Raanan (X) Jameis Winston has a real chance to keep J.J. McCarthy on the bench.
- Oct 3 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) J.J. McCarthy said that it was a “shock” to be traded from the Vikings to the Giants, but that he’s looking at it as an opportunity to show what he can do in the NFL. Story via @JordanRaanan+2
- Oct 3 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants Mailbag: Andrew Thomas' Health, J.J. McCarthy's Timeline and the Pass Rush Problem
-
Giants Jameis Winston Opens Up on Job Security After J.J. McCarthy Trade
8 more updatesfrom 6 sources
- Oct 1 Jordan Schultz (X) #Bills DE Greg Rousseau’s top 5 NFL pass rushers - in no particular order and not including himself! • Myles Garrett • Chase Young • Aidan Hutchinson • Will Anderson Jr. • Danielle Hunter “The list can keep going on and on!” · Quoting Jordan Schultz: 🚨 #Bills star DE and NFL sack leader Greg Rousseau joined me this week on The Schultz Report. I also give some intel on the latest NFL news — including the #Giants’ trade for JJ McCarthy and the why behind it. 👀 📺 WATCH NOW
- Oct 1 Pro Football Talk Jameis Winston on J.J. McCarthy: I have to play well regardless of who else is here
- Oct 1 Pat Leonard (X) All 9 routes · Quoting Madden NFL 27: You're calling J.J. McCarthy's first snap in Big Blue. What's the play? #Madden27 roster update drops tonight.
- Oct 1 Pat Leonard (X) No Andrew Thomas or Malik Harrison (with trainer) again today. Tyrone Tracy back on the field Hope for Deonte Banks and Tyler Nubin to return Sunday, it seems. Another VERY quick open practice period. J.J. McCarthy participating but doing plenty of watching/listening (helmet off, picking people’s brains as the other two QBs were rotating in walkthrough and routes on air) #Giants
- Oct 1 Pat Leonard (X) You're calling J.J. McCarthy's first snap in Big Blue. What's the play? #Madden27 roster update drops tonight.
- Oct 1 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants' Shelby Harris Says J.J. McCarthy Landed in the Right Place at the Right Time
- Oct 1 Dan Duggan (X) When you play out the best-case scenario for this season, it has to include getting on a roll during this upcoming stretch of the schedule. So for all of the JJ McCarthy intrigue, the season really hinges on Jameis Winston turning it around quickly · Quoting SNY Giants: When is the earliest the Giants could turn to J.J. McCarthy at quarterback? @Connor_J_Hughes and @DDuggan21 on NYG411
- Oct 1 Alec Lewis (X) Recorded an Ep of @AlecLewisShow last night talking J.J. McCarthy trade, offense & defense vs. Bucs and more...
- Oct 1 Patricia Traina (Bluesky) Giants Jameis Winston Opens Up on Job Security After J.J. McCarthy Trade
-
Quarterbacks on the Giants’ list of options include free agent Jimmy Garoppolo, Cardinals backup Gardner Minshew II, Vikings reserve J.J. McCarthy, 49ers backup Mac Jones and Chiefs backup Justin Fields.
More via NFLN and ESPN
2 more updatesfrom 2 sources
- Sep 27 NFL Daily News (Bluesky) Rap: Giants mulling QB options that includes Jimmy Garoppolo Gardner Minshew JJ McCarthy Mac Jones Justin Fields
- Sep 27 Adam Schefter (mirror, Bluesky) Quarterbacks on the Giants’ list of options include free agent Jimmy Garoppolo, Cardinals backup Gardner Minshew II, Vikings reserve J.J. McCarthy, 49ers backup Mac Jones and Chiefs backup Justin Fields. More via NFLN and ESPN+1
- The Nonsensical J.J. McCarthy Trade Rumors Have Started
- NFL Week 1 overreactions and exaggerations
- A Brief Refresher on the Emergency Quarterback Rules
- Vikes Views: 2026 Season Preview
-
#Vikings GM Nolan Teasley says QB J.J. McCarthy has practiced fully the last two days. Expects him on roster Week 1.
“Pleased that he’s part of the present version of the Minnesota Vikings and excited about his future.”
6 more updatesfrom 4 sources
- Sep 2 Vikings Team Site Nolan Teasley on Vikings Roster Build, Kyler Murray's Trajectory & J.J. McCarthy's Role
- Sep 2 Alec Lewis (X) Here's what Vikings GM Nolan Teasley had to say about QB J.J. McCarthy
- Sep 2 ESPN NFL News Vikings GM expects McCarthy on Week 1 roster+1
- Sep 2 Alec Lewis (X) Vikings GM Nolan Teasley: "I wouldn't necessarily comment on (quarterback) depth immediately, but I'm pleased that he's part of our present version of the Minnesota Vikings, and I'm excited about (J.J. McCarthy's) future." · Quoting Alec Lewis: Vikings GM Nolan Teasley said QB J.J. McCarthy has practiced fully the last two days. When asked if he expects him to be on the roster in 2026, Teasley said: "I do." He did not want to wade into whether or not McCarthy would be the backup quarterback.
- Sep 2 Alec Lewis (X) Vikings GM Nolan Teasley said QB J.J. McCarthy has practiced fully the last two days. When asked if he expects him to be on the roster in 2026, Teasley said: "I do." He did not want to wade into whether or not McCarthy would be the backup quarterback.
- Sep 2 Will Ragatz (X) Vikings GM Nolan Teasley on J.J. McCarthy's role: "J.J. McCarthy's role is to continue to develop, to improve, and to support his teammates. He's done an excellent job of that from the moment that I've been here, and from my understanding, since he walked through the door."
-
If the #Jets decide to dive into the backup QB market, some possibilities:
Andy Dalton (Frank Reich connection)
Tanner McKee
Sam Ehlinger (Reich connection)
Dillon Gabriel
Aidan O'Connell
Will Levis
J.J. McCarthy
Sam Howell
Jake Browning
Josh Johnson
1 more updatefrom 1 source
- Aug 30 Alec Lewis (X) This deal — and the Quinn Ewers trade from yesterday — provide a pretty clear picture of QB value right now. Both players offer more years of control than J.J. McCarthy. Neither comes with the guaranteed money that J.J. McCarthy has. These layers complicate a potential trade. · Quoting Adam Schefter: Trade: Packers are sending QB Kyle McCord to the Miami Dolphins in exchange for a 2028 6th-round pick, per sources. After trading Quinn Ewers to the Jaguars, the Dolphins needed a new backup for Malik Willis. Now the Dolphins have two former Packers QBs.
- Aug 30 Rich Cimini (X) If the #Jets decide to dive into the backup QB market, some possibilities: Andy Dalton (Frank Reich connection) Tanner McKee Sam Ehlinger (Reich connection) Dillon Gabriel Aidan O'Connell Will Levis J.J. McCarthy Sam Howell Jake Browning Josh Johnson
- J.J. McCarthy: Remains with Vikings
- Part of the J.J. McCarthy discourse that continues to get overlooked: He was trying to do something (have a viable career after missing his entire rookie year with injury) that basically never happens in the NFL, especially at quarterback. It sets you back in so many ways, intangible or otherwise
- Some potential QB options out there if Jets are looking to add via waivers/trade: - Andy Dalton (PHI): Would be an ideal mentor for Klubnik - Tanner McKee (PHI): Would appear price has gone down since he’s been not good in preseason - Aidan O’Connell (LV): He’d be high on my list if he breaks free. Has been OK, some NFL experience. Can do the job in a pinch. Only 27. - Dillon Gabriel (CLE): Had a good preseason finale - Sam Ehlinger (DEN): Played for Frank Reich in 2022. - Josh Johnson (CIN): Jets legend - Kyle McCord (GB): Had a really good preseason - JJ McCarthy (MIN): Idk man - Joe Fagnano (BAL): UDFA, had a good preseason - Will Levis (TEN): I wouldn’t but 🤷🏻♂️
- Jim Harbaugh doubled down on J.J. McCarthy: “I think he’s the best quarterback in the draft,” he said from AFC coaches breakfast. Says a ‘killer comes out’ when adversity hits.